Talk:Toronto Blessing
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Christianity, an attempt to build a comprehensive guide to Christianity on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can edit this article, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion. If you are new to editing Wikipedia visit the welcome page to become familiar with the guidelines. | ||
| Start | This article has been rated as Start-class on the quality scale. | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the importance scale. | ||
 |
This article is supported by WikiProject Charismatic Christianity. (with unknown importance) | ||
|
Assessment comments
|
|||
[edit] John and Carol Arnot link
The link is to one John Arnot who lived during the latter part of the 19th century. My guess is that this is not the current pastor of TACF. Could someone provide the correct link. Gracias!Jlujan69 00:11, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
Alright, how come my signature doesn't show when I type in four tildes?Jlujan69 00:11, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
Aha! I see what happened. I somehow was not logged in before commenting. Hmm.Jlujan69 00:11, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
The link for John Arnot on this page is indeed incorrect. I have no information about John Arnott who is the Pastor of this 'church'. I have however been heavily involved with a church in Scotland that was very much influenced by the Toronto Airport Fellowship and I firmly believe that its teachings and practices are so far removed from mainstream Christianity that it qualifies as a cult rather than church. This view is also held by several Christian theologians.
Although the view that this is a cult is held by several Christian theologians, this is in no way proof that it is a cult. Having been loosely connected with this church for about ten years, I can assure you there is nothing cultish about it. Cults are controlling of their people, discourage them from any other knowledge or teaching than what is in their own house, and demand 100% allegiance. TACF and John Arnott do none of these. Speakers at their conferences come from different denominations. People are free to come and go as they please. They encourage people to test all they teach against the Bible, and they release people at a very high rate. The teach the love of God the father, relationship with Jesus and God and the people to be the utmost priority, move away from a works based mentality into a grace based faith where you know who you are in Christ, and above all else to walk in the love of God and give it away to the world. Could you please tell me what is cultish or unBiblical about this? I wish I could say the same for most mainstream churches out there that claim TACF to be unBiblical or a cult.
[edit] Bath, England
I have lived here all my life and have never known the city to be famous for revival of the toronto blessings. any comments? 86.134.216.101 17:05, 4 September 2006 (UTC)
I don't really know anything about this subject but this article seems really sloppt, almost to the point of being unreadable. It could use an edit.
24.81.247.235 00:28, 25 September 2006 (UTC)
Both John Arnott and Benny Hinn have admitted to being influenced by Kathryn Kuhlman who was a charasmatic pentecostalist in the 50 and 60s. Benny Hinn has said that he actually recieves an annoiting from her bones in her grave. John Arnott's church Toronto Airport Christian Fellowship has a website that sells loads of stuff like special prayer mats, relaxation cds and aromatic oils. If this church is emailed and asked to explain why they do certain practices like 'soaking in the spirit' and so on there will never be any reply. Other churches that follow the lead from TACF will not reply either. This may be a condition of the cult or more than likely because there is no biblical basis whatsoever for what is taught and practised in this movement. I noticed that my critisms about the TACF have been recently removed by the user who praised that church. Please explain why? Everything I wrote was true. In brief, if you want to follow the teachings of John Arnott then do so, however it has to be accepted that these beliefs are not consistent with christian doctrines that have been helf for the last 2 thousand years. Sorry if you dont like.
The reason why they don't reply is simple. You aren't looking for an explanation, you are looking to prove them wrong. You have already assumed they are wrong and anything they say will be useless. Just because they don't answer you or practice apologetics does not make them a cult. Prayer mats? Please tell me what's wrong with that. 2000 years ago they were in wide use. Relaxation cd's? Sure, I listen to them as well. Nothing like having my quiet time with a quiet cd playing in the back ground with someone singing praise and worship to Jesus and God. What is wrong with that? Correct me if I am wrong, but didn't David call for a minstrel to play something soothing while he meditated? And as for the oils, these are annointing oils, not aromatherapy as you may think. Again, very Biblical. As for 'soaking', you are caught up in terminology. This is a term used to describe the modern equivalent of tarrying, meditating in the spirit, etc..., all things done over the centuries by Christians and followers of God, and all very Biblical. RESPONSE: yes I agree that the TACF does not dictate or abuse people like cults. I wrote the above comments that you are commenting on and I will briefly explain what I mean. Christianity has survived for the last 2,000 years simply through its passing on of doctrines and acceptance that the Bible is the word of God. I am not suggesting for one moment that the Christian experience is simply a matter of knowing scripture or being able to explain doctrine, obviously it is also a deep and meaningful relationship with God that is allowed through what Jesus suffered on the cross. I was involved with a church in Scotland that was very much influenced by what goes on in Toronto and I can assure you and others of the following. The shaking, falling, impersonation of animals, and loud screams are a learned behaviour and not initiated by the Holy Spirit. I saw several people shaking and shouting and claiming to have been 'filled' with the spirit and yet these same people would stand up again and go back into adulterous relationships or continue living totally dishonest lives!!! (yes we are all sinners, I know, however I believe that had the Holy Spirit truely been upon these people there would have been conviction of sinful activities that dominated their lives on a daily basis. This type of Charasmatic church tends to also have people who cannot explain even the most simple tenets of their faith. At the church that I attended we were visited by Steven Long from the TACF and he wanted to pray for 'gold teeth'. He suggested that we look into each others mouths for regular fillings before he prayed so that we would know whether or not they had been replaced with gold fillings. The pastor's wife allowed the person beside her to look into her mouth and guess what!! she already had a gold filling, but claimed she had no idea how it got there. Despite the church never ever being presented with dental records we were all told that she had been miracously given a gold filling, (I was there, she had the gold before the special prayer). I have watched videos from TACF and saw people claiming that God has told them to howl!!. well not sure what God is being worshipped there but the God that I am in fellowship with tells me that He loves me and sacraficed his own Son for me, that He loves all of humanity and longs to be in relationship with them, that he cares for the poor, sick and lonely and has a desire to be reconcilled with his creation. It is intersting that the Bible teaches that there would be false teachers in the last days, these teachers are not going to be the Jehova witnesses or the likes but rather part of the body of Christ. Lastly, are you aware that both John Arnott and Benny Hinn both claim to have been 'inspired' by Katherine Kulhman? Hinn even claims to get an annointing from the bones in her grave!! I suggest that you look at Kulhman videos that are online and compare what she was doing to what Hinn and Arnott are doing and tell me if Toronto is indeed anything new?? laurarossjessica@yahoo.com.au —Preceding unsigned comment added by 220.253.8.222 (talk) 00:17, 11 September 2007 (UTC)
In answer to your question about Bath, yes - my church "Bath City Church" is a charismatic evangelical church of about 500+ members, which meets in the Forum, and is linked with the TACF and is under the "Partners in Harvest" organisation. See www.bathcitychurch.org.uk 91.108.85.156 (talk) 22:21, 16 March 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Neutrality?
I just stumbled on this article looking for information, and it seems rather biased to me. Quotes such as the following, for instance, aren't really helpful:
(It's a fact that Toronto Airport Christian Fellowship is not a church but a fellowship run by a family owned benevolent dictator Pastor John Arnott who has his wife Carol on the five man board along with his right hand man Pastor Steve Long to ensure that they have the monopoly and control. Yes it's not a democratic run nonprofit organization or a church owned and run by members. If John Arnott had any integrity he would have a 12 man board just like Billy Graham Evangelistic Organization? And Pastor Steve Long would not tell lies about others and be a proven coward – The Liar )
Because of that I put up a neutrality tag.
an the x student from Toronto School of Ministry please explain why her personal encounters with this 'church' should be considered in a debate about whether or not TACF is a church or a cult? The purpose of this page was to help determine whether or not John Arnott has a 'church' that is consistent with the tenents of Christianity. So glad to hear that you went on to do a theology degree and mission work. Before doing a theology degree myself I ran playgroups for infants, does this mean that playgroups should be seen as part of the Church. Also with reference to having your confidence built up.... this is cleary a beneficial thing for Christians, however again this in itself does not make the Toronto church correct in its teachings or practices. Also I bet you paid a lot of money to have this confidence building experience. Sadly it is my experience that when people come to realise that the false prophecies, and delusions that such 'churches' cause are taken from them and reality sets text taken from the website? If they were added, please remove them, this is not an exact representation of the quote and therefore is biased in its nature, and quite frankly, not very helpful! No I did not get this from a website!!! I am more than capable of writing my own views on matters without cutting and pasting on a website. I wrote the comment based on my experience at a psychiatric nurse who also has a degree in theology, unlike people who attend TACF and the likes I am able to discern!!. I hope that my comments were left on long enough to help at least one person who may be struggling mentally just now with these false teachings.
- It seems to me that the 'offending' text has gone. Any need for this neutrality tag to remain? Alpheus 18:00, 1 December 2007 (UTC)
