Talk:The Sign and the Seal

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is clearly just a dump of an opinion piece written by Gil Kezwer; it may even have been added by the author himself, and I can find no trace of it searching for terms on Google. It is unlikely that this piece carries no copyright, and as such, unless it was contributed by the author himself (a possibility so distinct that I have refrained from adding a copyright warning for now), it would constitute a violation of the copyright agreement.

Since it is an opinion piece, it also violates Neutral point of view. This article is, certainly, not fit as an encyclopaedia entry at any rate and much be rewritten.

--Sbp 12:16, 1 May 2005 (UTC)

I Agree on the previous, that a rewrite is needed. The whole article is a laugh: it contains only Gil Kezwer's person opinion, there is virtually on info about the book itself (i.e. chapters), furthermore there is nothing about Atlantis in this book, as Gil Suggests. I will make a rewrite ASAP, possibly in the upcoming weekend.

Patrick1982 22:25, 30 May 2005 (UTC)

Made a cursory copyedit. Needs alot more. JDR 20:23, 26 August 2005 (UTC)