Strong two clubs

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article concerns contract bridge and uses terminology associated with the game. See Contract bridge glossary for an explanation of unfamiliar words or phrases.

In most natural bridge bidding systems, the opening bid of 2♣ is used exclusively for hands too strong for an opening bid at the one-level. That includes Standard American, standard Acol, 2/1 game forcing and most others. Typically, such a hand would contain at least 21 high card points or at least 8 tricks with any suit as trumps.

In Charles Goren's original bidding system, and "traditional" Acol, all the opening bids of two of a suit signified a very strong hand. This later became known as the strong two bid. However, pioneer bridge inventors like Pierre Albarran and David Burnstine^[1] saw that the frequency of such bid is fairly low, and that a 2♣ bid can be used for all strong hands, leaving other two-level opening bids for other purposes.

1 Responses
2 Advantages
3 Disadvantages
4 Other treatments
5 References

[edit] Responses

Please help improve this section by expanding it.
Further information might be found on the talk page or at requests for expansion.

[edit] Natural Responses

With "natural" responses, which is the most commonly used treatment, the 2♦ bid is artificial and very weak (6 high card points maximum). Each other bid is natural and positive. ^[2] .

[edit] "Three Point Step" Responses

A very simple convention of "Three Point Step" responses to a strong 2♣ opening bid is growing rapidly in popularity, especially among talented newer players. In this simple convention, the responder specifies the high card strength of his or her hand, without regard to distribution, as follows.

> 2♦ = 0-3 High Card Points (HCP); Very Weak. The responder normally will bid again only to show a long suit (5 or more cards) or a trump fit, but shoul use "Garbage Stayman" or "Garbage Transfers" if appropriate whenever opener's rebid is 2NT. The opening bidder obviously needs more than minimum values (at least 25 HCP) or a good trump fit to go to game.

> 2♥ = 4-6 HCP; Alertable and Game Forcing. Subsequent bids are natural, seeking a trump fit, typically with "systems on" (Stayman and transfers in effect) if opener rebids 2NT showing a balanced hand.

> 2♠ = 7-9 HCP; Alertable and Slam Inviting. Subsequent bids are natural, seeking a trump fit, typically with "systems on" (Stayman and transfers in effect) if opener rebids 2NT showing a balanced hand. Opener must have extra values (at least 25 HCP) or a good trump fit to go to slam.

> 2NT = 10 or more HCP; Alertable and Slam Forcing. Subsequent bids are natural, seeking a trump fit, typically with "systems on" (Stayman and transfers in effect) if opener rebids 3NT showing a balanced hand.

> Over interference, a DOUBLE (alertable) by responder shows a stolen bid (that is, the responder would have made the interfering bid in the absence of the interference) and a PASS shows any inferior bid. This treatment results in loss of granularity only if the interfering bid is 2♠ or higher.

If requested, the explanation of an alert should describe the meaning of the bid completely; for example:

> "My partner's response of 2♥ shows 4-6 HCP, and is game forcing. It says nothing whatsoever about distribution, and in particular neither shows nor denies hearts."

> "My partner's double of 2♠ shows 7-9 HCP, and is slam inviting. It says nothing whatsoever about distribution, and in particular neither shows nor denies spades."

This convention for response has two significant advantages and two relatively minor disadvantages over other responses. The first advantaage is that the 2♦ "Drop dead!" response alerts the opening bidder to partner's weakness immediately, while there's plenty of room to find a safe landing spot, when partner's hand is too weak to go on to game -- which happens quite often in actual play. The second major advantage is that it immediately tells the opening bidder the combined high card strength of the two hands to within one HCP, and thus the most probable optimal level to which to bid (with the caveat that one sometimes can go a level higher with a good trump fit). The first drawback is that the weaker hand occasionally will end up declaring a contract with a trump fit in the major suit of the response. (Note that a transfer following opener's rebid of 2NT over a response of either 2♥ or 2♠ may be to the suit of the response. Such transfers cannot achieve the objective of making the strong hand the declarer, but they still help to find such a trump fit.) The second drawback is that it uses up some bidding space if the responder has an unusually strong hand. Nonetheless, opener's minimum of 22 HCP leaves a maximum of 18 HCP distributed among the other three hands. It's quite rare for responder to hold more than half of them. Indeed, this convention has gained popularity both for its simplicity (comparable to standard Blackwood) and for the infrequent occurrence and relatively minor consequences of its drawbacks.

The origin of this convention is uncertain. Some players have attributed it to Oswald Jacoby, of Jacoby Transfer fame, while others refer to it as "Castlebury" (or "Castleberry"?), but the present author is not aware of any source that would verify either attribution.

[edit] Waiting and positive 2 diamonds

Some players alter or reverse the order of natural responses in order to preserve bidding space and allow for more accuracy in later bidding. There are several treatments in circulation:

Waiting 2♦ – in this treatment, bid of 2♦ can contain substantial values, but without a suit good enough for natural bid. Some players go as far to require a 6-card suit with 2 top honors for a suit response. It can be combined with:
- Weak 2♥. If 2♦ is (semi-)positive, then the response of 2♥ shows a very bad hand (0-4 HCP)
Positive 2♦ – in this treatment, only the bid of 2♦ shows values, and all other bids show less than 7 HCP.
Positive 2♥ – In this treatment, If 2♥ show a (semi-)positive, and 2♦ a negative (0-4 HCP)

[edit] Control-showing responses

Some players prefer to show their controls (high cards) rather than suits in the response to two-club opening bid. This has an advantage in cases when the opener has a strong one- or two-suiter (i.e. has an interest in cover cards rather than finding the suit fit), but can take up bidding space and miss a suit fit when the opener is balanced or semi-balanced:

With step responses, the responder counts controls (aces count as two controls, kings as one). He then uses steps to indicate the number of controls with 2♦ indicating 0 or 1 control, 2♥ 2 controls, 2♠ 3 controls etc.
With ace-showing responses, the responder bids the suit of the Ace he has, 2NT with two or more kings, and 2♦ with a king or less. With (unlikely) 2 aces, he bids 3♥. As a corollary, subsequent Blackwood by the opener asks for kings rather than aces.

[edit] Either-or treatment

Some players play that 2♣ can also contain a weak variant, for example the 2♦ weak two bid. In this scheme, 2♦ by responder is a waiting bid, asking the opener to describe his hand further if he is strong. If the opening hand has a weak two bid in diamonds, he should pass. However, if the responder has a strong hand, typically 15 high card points or more, he responds with 2NT. This treatment is often subject to restrictions in tournament play, as it has a destructive potential—see Bridge convention#Regulations.

[edit] Advantages

One major advantage of the artificial opening bid of 2♣ for all types of strong hands is that other opening bids at the two-level (2♦, 2♥ and 2♠) become available for weak two bids, thus eliminating many possible bids for the opponents. These weak two hands appear 20 times as often as the very strong hands, which illustrates the inefficiency of reserving all opening bids at the two-level for very strong hands.

Another advantage is the relative precision with which strong balanced hands can be bid. An opening bid of 2 No Trump indicates a balanced hand with 20 - 22 high card points, and for even stronger balanced hands, the opening bid of 2♣ can be used. The opener's second bid (in these cases always in No Trump) then indicates the strength of the hand using steps of two high card points.

[edit] Disadvantages

If the opening bid of 2♣ is exclusively used for strong hands, the auction becomes more susceptive to disruptive (jump) overcalls (especially when the opposing partnership is not vulnerable) than the "old" treatment of strong two bids. However, that danger is smaller when compared to strong 1♣ system in strong club systems, because 2♣ bid is made with bigger high-card strength and on a higher level. On the other hand, strong 2♣ opening reduces the bidding space for the pair themselves compared with strong 1♣—sometimes, the pair can be unable to find a fit on a relatively low level (below 3NT), and/or reduce the space for effective slam investigation with cue bidding.

[edit] Other treatments

In most strong club systems, the opening bid of 2♣ is natural and promises a hand with long clubs (for example, in both Precision and Blue club, it shows 11-15 high card points and either a 6-card club suit or at least a 5-card club suit and a 4-card major suit). As such, it makes overcalls more difficult, since they have to be made at the two-level. Chances are therefore increased that the side of the opener has an undisturbed auction, and the opponents won't discover a fit in a major suit. However, as a corollary, their strong 1♣ opening bid is more susceptible to preempting by opponents.