User talk:SRwiki

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Why have 3 french vets been moved?

I am just wondering why 3 of the French vets, have suddenly moved into the unverified category? After much discussion, in December I thought we had come to a reasonable consensus, about who was listed where, and my understanding was that all 3 were recognised as vets in our definition rather than the stricter (and western front orientated) French definition. The moving of the Italian vet who is living in France suggests that who-ever has taken it upon themselves to do this, doesn't understand how the page is laid out. If this vet has been moved because he has not been verified by the French Government, then there is no reason why he would be, he is a veteran of the Italian army - people do move around. Can whoever has done this moving please explain their reasoning? thanks SRwiki 18:44, 17 January 2007 (UTC)

In France, there are only three official WWI veterans.

• De Cazenave, Louis
• Grelaud, Jean
• Ponticelli, Lazarre

The other one do not have the right qualifications to be on this list... I didn't know where to put this other vet so I put them in the last part of the article

Paris75000 21:02, 17 January 2007 (UTC)

Thanks for replying, but I think you are using a different definition of a vet to the rest of us. As far as I can tell the official French definition accepts only those with more than 3 months service, on the Western Front. The definition we are using here, is service anywhere, for any length of time up to 11/11/1918. I suspect the official French definition, is for the purposes of who gets a war pension, rather than who is a veteran.

If you scroll through this discussion page, you will see we have discussed this in great detail

In the case of two of these Vets 1 served in Syria, and one for less than three months, so although not on the official list, are still veterans. The Third vet you moved is an ITALIAN, who just happens to now be living in France, he is never going to be classed as a French Veteran, because he was never in the French Army. But he is an undisputed Veteran of the Italian Army.SRwiki 07:55, 18 January 2007 (UTC)

Hi

I just made some modifications to show exactly what are the official and non official living WWI vets in France. I hope you will enjoy them (I think I striked the right balance)

Sincerily

Paris75000 09:00, 18 January 2007 (UTC)

WP link :Surviving veterans of World War I