Talk:Social psychology/Scoring chart Feb06
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
| Section | Rank | Reasoning |
| Individual |
||
| Action model | SP |
not a theory, just a model |
| Hedonism | SP |
happiness may be either creative striving or obedience/socialization |
| Erik Erikson | SP |
not a theory, just a model |
| Maslow/needs | PSP |
The needs themselves are beyond agency or structure, but the choice toward what basic needs are sought to be satisfied first are up to the agent |
| Affect control | PSP |
See no reason to attribute this to anything but the individual |
| Constructivist school | SSP |
Everything is a social construct, so the entirety is social structural |
| Realist/Ekman school | SSP & PSP |
To do with, in part, innate emotional expressions, and in part with socially learned forms of expression |
| Emotion theories | PSP |
Locus of control is seemingly internal regardless of whether James or conventional view is correct |
| Allman | SP |
Biological level of explanation; is beyond agency-structure debate |
| Fundamental attribution error | SP |
If this behavior is a choice, it is not clear on what basis |
| Social comparison theory | PSP |
Seemingly internally-directed |
| Attitudes | SP |
Locus of control seems unaffected in both Bem and Fishbein |
| ToMM | SP |
Again, not relevant to agency-structure debate. If there is a module, then it seems beyond an agent's control |
| Pattern recog | SP | Basic predisposition, nothing to do with agency/structure |
| Philosophical apps | SP |
Nature of self wrt identity, but not wrt choices or socialization |
| Psychodynamic | SP |
Is more internal than external, but not clear that it's under the control of the individual |
| Social behaviorism | SSP |
Mind dependent upon external interaction; obviously external |
| Vygotsky | PSP & SSP |
scaffolding = SSP; actual development level = PSP |
| Meaning/selfconcept | SP |
most concepts here have to do with the tools involved in the making of a self; nothing implied about locus of control (except, possibly, role models mention) |
| Big 5 personality | SP |
Phenomenon, no causes speculated |
| Dominance personality | SP |
Phenomenon, no causes speculated |
| Implicit personality theories | SP |
Phenomenon, no causes speculated |
| Sense of community | SSP |
Has to do with external forces, peoples; not especially within the domain of PSP except wrt distortions in perception |
| Soc identity | SSP |
Social identity is necessarily about social structures |
| Place attachment | SP |
Phenomenon, no speculation into causes |
| Formation strategies | PSP & SSP |
both choice/commitment and community are criteria here |
| Interaction |
||
| Helping models | PSP & SSP |
bystander effect = SSP, cost/benefit = PSP |
| Aggression models | PSP & SSP |
social learning theory of aggression = SSP, catharsis = PSP |
| Suicide | SSP |
integration = external locus of control |
| Communication paradigm | SP |
just a model, not a theory |
| Elaboration likelihood model | SP |
equally applicable to PSP/SSP |
| Soc impact | SSP |
Power and social structure make an appearance; but arguably both PSP and SSP |
| Functionalism | SSP |
based upon social structures |
| Sym.-interactionism | PSP & SSP |
Generalized and significant others = extra loci |
| Romance | PSP |
Predominantly agentic sources of action |
| Power | SSP |
Power = social structural (with the exception of dependency, which may not be) |
| Trust | SP (??) |
Not enough info to say, entry is too sketchy |
| Collectives |
||
| Cohesion | PSP & SSP |
emergence = PSP; group structure = SSP |
| Boundaries | SP |
phenomenon, no (relevant) causes speculated |
| Conflict | Some PSP, but mostly SSP |
contract = PSP, others = SSP |
| Work performance | SSP |
Seemingly exhausted by social structural considerations |
| Decision-making | PSP & SSP |
leadership charisma = PSP (of leader), social ties = SSP |
| Collective | PSP |
Emergent behaviors en masse don't seem to have to do with social structures (arguable) |
| Self in context | SSP |
Social context is the emphasis |
| Deviance | PSP & SSP |
anomie = PSP, control = SSP |
| Intergroup conflict | SSP |
conflicting common goals = conflicting structures |
| SID of Intergroup conflict | SSP |
social identity = SSP |
| ---- | ||
| SP: 19/47 PSP: 6/47 |
||
