User talk:Shorens

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

If the stores are independent , what are they doing in the article for the Dartmouth Crossing Mall? They are not considered notable content. Do not add spam to WP.

[edit] Dartmouth Crossing

Honestly, you object to every edit I made? Including the addition of new references and facts? If you object to the deletion of tenant lists, then add the list back. But a wholesale revert is incredibly inappropriate. Skeezix1000 22:05, 23 July 2007 (UTC)

Just to add, WP:CON isn't a tool to use to frustrate efforts by other editors to bring an article in line with policies and guidelines. There is a discussion on the talk page why the tenant lists are inappropriate. You are entitled to disagree, but the appropriate course of action would be to actually explain why you believe the policies and guidelines do not apply here, and which policies and guidelines support the inclusion of the tenant lists. I was bold in editing the article because there had been no response to the last sets of comments, and no objections to the removal of the tenant lists beyond "it's useful". We're all anxious to improve the article -- explain in more detail why you believe the tenant lists to be appropriate. Skeezix1000 22:20, 23 July 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Halifax Shopping Centre

Reverting someone's edits and removing tags without explanation or even a note in the edit summary is really inapproriate. You need to source the information in the article. First, you need a source that shows that there is such a thing as an "unaffiliated anchor" and that identifies Real Atlantic Wholesale Club, The Bay and Shopper's Drug Mart as such. Second, you need a source that identifies Banana Republic, The Gap, Club Monaco, M•A•C Cosmetics, Birks Jewellery, The Children's Place, Town Shoes, and Pier 1 as "prominent" retailers within the centre (otherwise, simply relying on your personal assessment that they are prominent violates WP:OR and WP:NPOV). Finally, you need a source that identifies Sears, Sears Outlet, Sobeys, Sport Chek/Coast Mountain Sports, Wal-Mart and Winners as anchor stores. Again, it is not up to Wikipedia editors such as ourselves to deem stores to be anchors or not -- we need to cite a reliable source as per WP:V. Thanks. Skeezix1000 21:04, 25 July 2007 (UTC)