Talk:Sheboygan

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I feel that Sheboygan can be moved to Sheboygan (disambiguation). Feel you don't have nothing good to say, don't leave a comment. Asher Heimermann 20:28, 21 January 2007 (UTC)

I actually don't feel all that strongly about whether the disambiguation page should be at Sheboygan or at Sheboygan (disambiguation) (I'm slightly inclined to leave the disambiguation page where it is, but I could be convinced otherwise). Trying to do this move by cutting and pasting the content without any discussion is bad form. However, quite apart from that, you haven't actually given any reason why the page should be moved. By your current suggestion, simply moving Sheboygan to Sheboygan (disambiguation) will result in a redirect from Sheboygan to Sheboygan (disambiguation) which is inappropriate. I suspect that the end result that you are seeking is to have Sheboygan redirect to Sheboygan, Wisconsin. You may want to make that explicit and provide some rationale for such a move. Otherwise, there's little reason to take your proposal seriously. Also, you may want to list this on Wikipedia:Requested moves to get a wider opinion. older ≠ wiser 20:42, 21 January 2007 (UTC)