User talk:Scoutersig/secession

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] First impression

Thank you for asking for my input. Are you intending this as a list or is this the skeleton of an article?

If you intend it as an article, you may want to add comments in the private page (maybe using a text style such as <small>...</small>). In particular, I would like to see how you're planning to flesh out the individual sections. Without this knowledge, all I can say that it's a nice collection of topics, and it is helpful for internal reference.

One thing I find particularly helpful is the distinction between "serious" and "humorous". Unfortunately, I don't know how to translate this to NPOV.

If you intend it as a list then I'm not so sure how useful it is for Wikipedia. We already have the category, and usually we try to convert lists to categories because they're easier to maintain. — Sebastian (talk) 21:31, 7 November 2006 (UTC)