User talk:Sccosel

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Hi Sccosel. Edits from 63.206.157.104 have now been reattributed to you. Regards — Kate Turner | Talk 03:12, 2004 Sep 4 (UTC)

Same for 68.99.182.143. Regards — Kate Turner | Talk 03:29, 2004 Sep 4 (UTC)

You said: "Why did you delete the external link to Who's Alive and Who's Dead on the Celebrity page? What Wikipedia Policy did it violate? I think it is quite informative as to whether or not a celebrity is alive or dead."

The information is (or should be) already available in the Wikipedia itself. See WP:EL for the policy that it violated. --Yamla 02:36, 29 June 2006 (UTC)

You said: "So, let me understand something... An external link that would be useful to all readers of an article can't be used if it "should be" on Wikipedia, but isn't? The person that updates the information on the webpage pointed to by this external link is extremely prompt in keeping it updated. S/he just isn't doing it on Wikipedia. So, just because they aren't maintaining constantly changing information on Wikipedia, the link shouldn't be in Wikipedia? And, what gives you the right to "police" (or maybe even a harsher word is in order) Wikipedia?"

Did you read WP:EL? Also, please see Category:Living People and Category:Dead people. --Yamla 03:28, 29 June 2006 (UTC)