User talk:Rozannsaaty

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I realize the inventor of AHP is your husband. That puts in a COI (conflict of interest) for editing this material. The mathematical proofs of known errors in AHP should not be deleted. If you have substantive rebutals, they should be included without removing the original criticism. I'm sure you have found that criticisms are aplenty of AHP, especially from those who study the decision sciences formally and at a mathematical level. For a neutral point of view, you cannot pretend that these criticisms and, for that matter, alternatives to AHP do not exist. If you disagree, I suggest you discuss it first in the discussion page of the article.Hubbardaie 02:20, 3 July 2007 (UTC)

[edit] My editing

Rosann Saaty, my background (with T. L. Saaty) is only my long ago attendence of a Project Management course guestlecture (J. Katz, 1991), and we all got a copy of "Thinking Mans Jokebook". And, I bought at least three mathematical 60's textbooks that had immense literature lists! Syski I never met, but I like his book on Congestion. My additions to their articles (I created Syski's) is solely based on interest, and (credible) biographical material Googled (and references to these). Obviously, please correct any mistakes I made (or erase unwanted items, as the article seemed fairly all right already -- it becomes a matter of personal taste of what goes into these biographical sketches -- as long as it is within (the highly variable) Wikipedias guidelines, I suppose). I have no insight into AHP, and have no comment on the dispute. Thanks for sending the message.Ketil3 (talk) 08:08, 28 November 2007 (UTC)