Talk:Rose Red

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Should this page be marked as a disambiguation???63.233.102.103 02:35, 15 July 2005 (UTC)

omgwtf stephen king book!

Should there also be some separation between the ACTUAL fairy tale character and her appearance in Fables? I don't mind having that as an "appearances in media" type subsection but the info about the Fables character is the majority of this article

[edit] i agree

i think this should be a disambiguation as it is directed from stephen king's rose red (a short mini tv series)

[edit] Spoiler

And shouldn't there be a Spoiler Warning before the line: "at one point Snow White survived a wound that would have killed almost anybody else"? I'm reading "Fables" now, and could have done without this info . . .

I fully agree. Even though I've read (most) of Fables to date, I still don't think spoiler information should be present here. Even more than that, I think there's too much about the character, when this particular article is about the fairy tale. If I'm not mistaken, the Fables character has her own page, and it should stay that way. 春・Harukaze・風 13:44, 24 February 2008 (UTC)

It shouldn't be removed just because it contains spoilers, Wikipedia contains spoilers. I agree that the removed material did not belong on this article, but at the Fables character's page, however, so I didn't replace it.--Cúchullain ^t/c 18:35, 24 February 2008 (UTC)

Oh I know that Wikipedia contains spoilers, I just thought that this was a bad place for it. I fully think that her character entry should show who she is up-to-date, which is precisely why I don't read any of the Fables articles right now :) Leastwise, not until I finish catching up in a couple weeks or so ^_^ 春・Harukaze・風 14:55, 25 February 2008 (UTC)