Talk:Roman Catholicism in India/Comments

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Check the article Roman_Catholicism_in_the_Vatican_City for an example of how to improve and expand the article. WP:WIAFA and/or WP:WIAGA may also help after this. Ncmvocalist 12:52, 15 October 2007 (UTC)

Unfortunately we cant redirect the page to India like Roman Catholicism in the Vatican City redirecting to Vatican City, isnt it? ώiki Ѕαи Яоzε ^†αLҝ 13:12, 15 October 2007 (UTC)

Please note that I want you to check the content of the article (ignore the irrelevant details like the fact that the page redirected)

I wanted you to check the content of the article, and note how it has been written, how it has been organised, how comprehensive it was and so on. However, I'm not sure why I cited this particular example that was on a city (??).

Still, I remember feeling (and still do feel) that the article did not have enough material needed for a comprehensive article. Although there are several citations (which is good, as long as the sources are both reliable/verifiable), and some areas of the article are covered very well, it has very little material under some headings (eg; "Pre-Catholic Christianity" and "Ecclessiastical Provinces"), suggesting that the article has not fully treated that topic under those headings. More detail is needed to make it comprehensive, (but take care not to make it too too much detail either). The Jammu and Kashmir of 2007 is a good example of an article that is rather comprehensive. It fully treats the different topics under its headings. Once this article treats the different topics fully, this article will receive a B grade upon reassessment. Keep it up! Ncmvocalist (talk) 13:35, 26 February 2008 (UTC)

Thanks, these comments are much helpful compared to the one given earlier. Cheers Wiki San Roze ^†αLҝ 14:04, 26 February 2008 (UTC)