Talk:Robert Rosner

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Note, this is not about the financial guy that was recently part of an AfD, but the astrophysicist, who is much more notable (director of a major government lab? I'd say that counts). --Whsitchy 02:20, 31 May 2007 (UTC)

Another edit earlier, so I've reverted the stuff about that rich chap, to get it back to being about the astrophysicist, in keeping with the AFD discussion. --Oscarthecat 16:51, 31 May 2007 (UTC)

This page, what there is of it, has only been setup to prove a point - that this Robert Rosner is more notable than the other Robert Rosner. The point might be correct but that's not the issue. I'm therefore not entirely comfortable this page is here. Georgethe23rd 19:42, 31 May 2007 (UTC)

I didn't make it for that reason. I only made it since A. the old page was deleted, and B. prevent recreation really. Do a yahoo or google search, and could you please tell me what page you have to go on to find the financial guy if you only use Robert Rosner as the search text. Whsitchy 20:58, 31 May 2007 (UTC)

When searching for the Robert Rosner, rich guy on google etc ... you find a lot of stuff, for example BIO, revenues, company owned, etc... I am not comfortable with having this scientist have his page we should create the page on the financial Robert Rosner and protect it so that it can't be changed. Because i don't think that having put some scientist on Wikipedia is better than having a financial mogul who has been victim of wikipedia vandals. Whilst flipping through the world Wealth Report 2007 the new one, his name figures right there 458th in the World... what should we do possibly put on the scientist page a section with like three sentences on the financial guy?? how about that or we could create a page on his son Alex and slip a sentence or two on his father as I here legal puirsuits may be in order if a page doesn't figure on him —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 86.211.188.111 (talk • contribs) 11:16, 25 July 2007.

Change this scientist guy replace it by the other guy