Wikipedia:Requests for publication/Common Unix Printing System

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Common Unix Printing System

Stable revision. - Ta bu shi da yu 11:23, 29 November 2005 (UTC) See also: Common Unix Printing System/Proposed baseline -- Zondor 02:35, 30 November 2005 (UTC)

Please note: This is only a demo version to flesh out ideas for establishing a stable article.

Please comment on each of the following areas:

[edit] Mandatory areas

There are areas that must be correct before the article can even be considered to be a stable article.

Structural

As with most articles of a computing nature, this has a history and an architectural overview. However, it has nothing on the various major versions that were released, though it does have information on specific vulnerabilities.

Accuracy & Verifiability

• I wrote the article, but I believe it to be accurate. This is obviously not a good way of deciding on the accuracy of any article, however. We need to discuss how we determine accuracy! One suggestion I have is to make a list of every fact on the page, and find out what the source for that fact is.

• There are sources, though are there enough?

Objectivity (Neutrality)

It got through FAC OK, and covers vulnerabilities and criticisms quite well. It also gives objective praise where it is due.

Readibility

I'd say it's pretty readable. It did get through FAC OK - I think this metric is satisfied by a successful FAC nomination.

[edit] Optional criteria

The following criteria are important, but not strictly necessary for a stable version.

Currency & comprehensiveness

Nothing on OS X.