Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Terryeo/Workshop

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is a page for working on Arbitration decisions. It provides for suggestions by Arbitrators and other users and for comment by arbitrators, the parties and others. After the analysis of /Evidence here and development of proposed principles, findings of fact, and remedies. Anyone who edits should sign all suggestions and comments. Arbitrators will place proposed items they have confidence in on /Proposed decision.

Contents

[edit] Motions and requests by the parties

[edit] Template

1)

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:


[edit] Proposed temporary injunctions

[edit] Template

1)

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo banned from Scientology related articles

1) Due to continued disruption Terryeo is banned from editing articles related to Dianetics or Scientology pending resolution of this request.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Proposed final decision

[edit] Proposed principles

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed principle}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] No personal attacks

1) Wikipedia:No personal attacks prohibits personal attacks.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] NPOV

2) Wikipedia:Neutral point of view contemplates fair expression of all significant points of view regarding a subject. The practice of first setting forth the viewpoint of the advocates of a positive viewpoint has been considered and rejected.

Comment by Arbitrators:
While I also advocate the policy Terryeo is advocating, it has been soundly rejected. Fred Bauder 12:59, 22 April 2006 (UTC)
Comment by parties:
Bauder's comment should be ignored. He is a member of the Wikinfo project, and is against the NPOV policy itself. His comment also says nothing about intepreting the NPOV policy, which is what this section is about. (His response is like hearing "I don't like green cars" when the question is "What shade of green is this car?") --Davidstrauss 05:59, 28 April 2006 (UTC)
Comment by others:

[edit] Edit warring

3) Edit warring is harmful. Content disputes should be resolved by recourse to verifiable sources and discussion, not repeated reverts of an article.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Tendentious editing

4) Users who engaged in aggressive, sustained point of view editing may be banned from affected articles, in extreme cases, from Wikipedia.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Talk pages

4) Wikipedia talk pages offer the opportunity for dialog. Removal of discussion by others hinders that necessary process.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed principle}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Proposed findings of fact

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed finding of fact}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Locus of dispute

1) Edits by Terryeo (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · block user · block log) to Dianetics and related articles.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Personal attacks by Terryeo

2) Terryeo has made personal attacks [1], [2].

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo's interpretation of NPOV

3) Terryeo's interpretation of NPOV, Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#First_assertion:_Editors_understand_the_stated_word_differently contains elements of the sympathetic point of view approach which has been considered and rejected by Wikipedia policy makers.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Xenu.net

4) Xenu.net (Operation Clambake) is not a personal website in the sense that it represents only the opinion of one person. It is a prominent website critical of Scientology.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Edit warring by Terryeo

5) Terryeo has engaged in edit warring of Scientology related articles Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#Edit_warring.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Tendentious editing by Terryeo

5) Terryeo has engaged in sustained aggressive point of view editing of articles which related to Scientology and Dianetics, see Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#POV_editing.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo has removed references

6) Terryeo has repeatedly removed references to sources, see Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#Removal_of_references_for_POV_reasons and Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#First_assertion.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo has removed others' postings to talk pages

7) Terryeo has removed material posted by others to talk pages, see Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo/Evidence#Inappropriate_removal_of_content_from_talk_pages.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed finding of fact}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed finding of fact}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Proposed remedies

Note: All remedies that refer to a period of time, for example to a ban of X months or a revert parole of Y months, are to run concurrently unless otherwise stated.

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed remedy}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo placed on personal attack parole

1) Terryeo is placed indefinitely on personal attack parole. He may be blocked briefly if he makes personal attacks, up to a week in the event of repeat offenses.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terreo banned from Scientology related articles

2) Terryeo is banned indefinitely from articles which relate to Dianetics or Scientology.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo placed on probation

3) Terryeo is placed on probation indefinitely. He may be banned from any article or page which he disrupts. Bans to be logged at Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo#Log_of_blocks_and_bans.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Terryeo placed on general probation

4) Terryeo is placed on general probation indefinitely. For good cause, any three administrators may ban Terryeo from Wikipedia. All bans to be logged at Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo#Log_of_blocks_and_bans.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed remedy}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Proposed enforcement

[edit] Template

1) {text of proposed enforcement}

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Enforcement by block

1) Bans may be enforced by brief blocks, up to a week for repeat offenses. After 5 blocks, the maximum block shall increase to one year. Blocks to be logged at Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Terryeo#Log_of_blocks_and_bans.

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] Analysis of evidence

Place here items of evidence (with diffs) and detailed analysis

[edit] Template

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others:

[edit] General discussion

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others: