Talk:Pit-house

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Page Improvements

I agree that the article needed improvement. My additions also require further refinement, organization, and better coding of the references. Some discussion of types and pictures would be useful. I would like to see the page moved to "Pit Structures". If people still wanted to use the term pit-house couldn't they simply link to pit structures and keep their language? If others agree, then I propose we move this page to pit structures.

Impressive work you've done! We've now got a large base of information to work with. Your addition contains highly technical data, so perhaps we can organize the skeleton, then incorporate the data/findings into the context of the sections. I have a feeling by the time this article's done, it will have grown several pages long. I agree on moving it. Have you noticed searching for "Pit house" (without the dash) brings up the article "Dugout (shelter)"? That article makes reference to pit houses under the People of the New World section. After this article is more refined, we can link it to here ^^. As for pictures, I'll see what I can find. Image editing isn't my specialty, but maybe a Sketchup model would serve nicely, especially to showcase the differences among cultures' architecture.User:BackToThePast 23:40, 27 June 2007 (UTC)

I'm sorry if I barge in, but I believe the word "Grubenhausen" is wrong. At least according to German grammar, it should be "Grubenhäuser" (or Grubenhaeuser), as it's the plural of "Grubenhaus". -- Firlefanz (who is German)

[edit] Expanding on the article

I propose going into more detail about how each culture used pit-houses and perhaps some pictures of each.

New Sections: "Types" or similar section going into detail about how each people used pit-houses i.e. Europe, North America "Construction" would provide a place to detail the construction of a pit-house, possibly with pics "See also", which would include a link to "Dugout (shelter)" "External links" to some sites with images and 3D models of real pit-houses

Introduction: At the beginning, it says "A pit house is a small house with double layered stone." This describes the sort of house usually found in Europe. Yet the next sentence, "It is dug into the ground and used by the Inuit people as places to tell stories, dance, sing and celebrate" focuses on only the Inuit's use of the pit-house. Changing cultures so quickly confuses people. What is (or what was) a typical pit-house? Using a prehistoric example would be a nice start, because those dwellings were common throughout the world far back in time, and served as the model for all later pit-houses. How about beginning the article with an introduction that doesn't center on a particular culture? Make a broad sweep of when, where, and how pit-houses were used across the world.--BackToThePast 15:09, 26 June 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Merge and shuffle two articles

I propose that the Dugout (shelter) article be used as a generic overview of the widespread archictectural type while the Pit-house article focus on the archaeological findings of these forms, particularly in the American Southwest. The Pit-house title might have to be changed. Opinions? WBardwin 01:41, 7 November 2007 (UTC)