User:Piotrus/Sandbox/RfC numbers

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Playing with numbers

Notes:

  1. ) Voting is evil... but it helps to know where the majority lies :)
  2. ) Votes by Piotrus or Ghirla not counted
  3. ) If Piotrus objected or Ghirla supported a statement, it's 'Ghirla support', and vice versa
  4. ) Neutrals, roughly, are those who blame both sides equally.
  5. ) Votes by users who specifically signed 'don't endorse section' are classified as minuses (again, not counting Piotrs or Ghirla's). As they affect only number of votes, and all support me only, I decided not to count them.
  6. ) Some individuals who supported neutral and one or both sides may be counted multiply times
  7. ) Individual count is likely more relevant, as voting count can be inflated by more active users who simply return to sign new views.
  8. ) Thus I decided to calculate totals for 'individuals supporting Piotrus', 'individuals supporting Ghirla' and 'neutral individuals'. If a user voted more then once in support of a given group, this was reduced to one vote (per 7) to eliminate bias for more active voters. Some users may belong to more then one group (per 6); that's ok - their vote will just give 'half strenght' to each of the two sides (and if a user would support all three groups, then his vote is averaged out and simply has no effect on percentages).

Exceptions to the above rules:

  1. ) I count Biruitorul outside view as neutral despite Ghirla's objection, as I think it fits neutral definition above
  2. ) I count Raul as support of myself despite Ghirla's endorsement of it;
  3. ) I count Yannismarou view as another one which supports myself, as Ghirla supporting it contradicts himself.

For statiscs will be shown, with and without exceptions, and with and without minuses. With exceptions counts Raul and Yanni's as supporting me, and Biru as neutral.

Ghirla support (i.e. Ghirla is mostly innocent, it's mostly Piotrus fault):

  1. ) Ghirla statement: MK + Mikka + JzG = 3
  2. ) Inside by MK: Dr. Dan = 2
  3. ) Calgacus outside: Dr. Dan + Catchpole + Giano + Matthead = 5
  4. ) Mikka: JzG + Dr. Dan + MK + Errabee = 5 - Contanz + Lysy + Beau + Apple + KP + Darw + RdH + log + Olessi = 5 - 9 = -4
  5. ) Errabee: Giano =2 - Apple + log = 2 - 2 = 0
  6. ) Matthead: = 1
This section is not affected by 'exceptions'.
With minuses: 7
W/out minuses: 18
Individuals: 8 (18 votes) - MK (3 votes), Mikka (2), JzG (2), Dr. Dan (3), Calgacus (1), Catchpole (1), Giano (2), Matthead (2), Errabee (2)
Indivuduals who signed this section only: 4 (MK, Catchpole, Mikka, Giano)
Individuals who signed posts in this section twice as much as in others: 2 (JzG, Dr. Dan)

Piotrus support (i.e. Piotrus is mostly innocent, it's mostly Ghirla's fault): :

  1. ) Piotrus statement: Darw + Bea + KL + Apple + Fol + Balc + KP + Tank + log = 9
  2. ) Ideogram outside: Good + Lysy + Apple + KP + log + Bea + Stifle = 8
  3. ) K. Last: Bea + Const + Mieciu + Lysy + KP + log + Olessi = 8
  4. ) Biruitorul: KL + Fol + Ist + Dahn + Bea + Lysy + Olessi + Stifle + Ch73= 10
  5. ) Raul outside (addressed only several of raised issue): Balcer, Bea, log, RDH = 5
  6. ) Yannismarou outside: Apple + Dr.Dan + RdH = 4
This section is not affected by 'minuses'.
Individuals w/out exceptions (+B, -R, -Y): 20 (34 votes) Darw (1), Bea (3), KL (3), Apple (2), Fol (2), Balc (1), KP (3), Tank (1), log (3), Ideo (1), Good (1), Lysy (3), Stifle (2), Const (1), Mieciu (1), Olessi (2), Biru (1), Ist (1), Dahn (1), Ch73 (1)
Individuals w/exceptions (-B, +R, +Y): 20 (33 votes) - Darw (1), Bea (3), KL (2), Apple (3), Fol (1), Balc (2), KP (3), Tank (1), log (4), Ideo (1), Good (1), Lysy (2), Stifle (1), Const (1), Mieciu (1), Olessi (1), Raul (1), RdH (2), Yanni (1), Dr. Dan (1)
Individuals who signed this section w/exceptions only: 4 (Darw, KP, Tank, Mieciu)
Individuals who signed posts in this section twice as much as in others: 1 (Apple)

Neutral (i.e. more or less, both sides are at fault italic indicates exception-affected statements):

  1. ) Elaragirl: Calg + Good + Add + Yand + More + KL + Dec + Shell + Anti + Hipo + Ch73= 12
  2. ) Biruitorul: KL + Fol + Ist + Dahn + Bea + Lysy + Olessi + Stifle + Ch73= 10
  3. ) Kusma: JzG + Angus + RdH = 4
  4. ) Raul outside (addressed only several of raised issue): Balcer, Bea, log, RDH = 5
  5. ) Yannismarou outside: Apple + Dr.Dan + RdH = 4
  6. ) RdH outside: KL + JzG + Kusma + Olessi + Ch73 = 6
  7. ) István: RdH + KL = 2
This section is not affected by 'minuses'.
Individuals w/out exceptions (-B, +R, +Y): 25 (33 votes) - Elaragirl (1), Calg (1), Good (1), Add (1), Yand (1), More (1), KL (3), Dec (1), Shell (1), Anti (1), Hipo (1), Ch73 (2), Kusma (2), JzG (2), Angus (1), RdH (4), Olessi (1), Ist (1), Raul (1), Balc (1), Bea (1), log (1), Yanni (1), Apple (1), Dr. Dan (1)
Individuals w/exceptions (+B, -R, -Y): 24 (37 votes) - Elaragirl (1), Calg (1), Good (1), Add (1), Yand (1), More (1), KL (4), Dec (1), Shell (1), Anti (1), Hipo (1), Ch73 (3), Kusma (2), JzG (2), Angus (1), RdH (3), Olessi (2), Ist (2), Bitu (1), Fol (1), Dahn (1), Bea (1), Lysy (1), Stifle (1)

Summary: 38 separate individuals. 53 sepearate votes w/out exceptions, 52 w/ exceptions.

Without exceptions: Ghirla-8 (15%) Piotrus-20 (37,7%) neutral-25 (47,1%)

With exceptions: Ghirla-8 (15,3%) Piotrus-20 (38,5%) neutral-24 (46,2%)