Talk:Pier Solar and the Great Architects

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I object against the deletion. I believe the game, having been noteable for various popular websites, as well as having a feature in the upcoming issue of Retro Gamer to be released on February 28th (a magazine with a Wikipedia-entry itself) should be enough for Wikipedia to keep the page. The game has a steady information-flow, and is noteable for being the first newly programmed game on the system in over a decade. It is just as noteworthy as games like Beggar Prince or Last Hope, also new releases for "dead" systems. The game even has a set release date.

I believe the effort of keeping Wikipedia "clean" is getting overhand, with overly strict views on what is relieable and noteworthy and what not; this hurts Wikipedia´s mission to give information. Here we have a game that is as noteworthy as a homebrew-game can be, with the only flaw that it is not released yet. Other homebrews have entries, but I believe that the fact they have already been released is not enough to make them so much more noteable than a game that has received as much attention as this one.108 Stars (talk) 14:51, 7 February 2008 (UTC)

[edit] Keep

The game has been worked on since 2004 and there are many different sources for its existence. News about it are coming regularly, which proves the project is alive and healthy. Zebbe (talk) 17:07, 7 February 2008 (UTC)