Talk:Philharmonia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I have removed the clause about "annual" appearances in Paris since the Philharmonia do not play there every year.--S.Camus 12:27, 9 July 2006 (UTC)

The footnote referring to Lebrecht is incorrect. Lebrecht does not mention the incident at all. --dunnhaupt 20:18, 26 September 2006 (UTC)

OK. Now, my reason for moving this page to a page that redirects to it (moving the "Philharmonia" page to the "Philharmonia Orchestra" page) is because only the title of the page referred to it as the Philharmonia when introdcing it. The opening paragraph and the title on the infobox, however, refer to it as the Philharmonia Orchestra (with the infobox referring to the name "Philharmonia" as a secondary name instead of a primary name), and therefore made me think that's what the article should be called, too. So if you object to this edit I have made, then please feel free to reverse it. --Kschwerdt514 21:06, 21 February 2007 (UTC)

...and in so doing, you completely wiped out the edit history. before moving a page you MUST bring the topic up for discussion BEFORE it is moved. --emerson7 | Talk 01:40, 22 February 2007 (UTC)

Not sure how these things are usually discussed (I've seen entire discussions archived and such), so I'll ask here.

Requesting page move to "Philharmonia Orchestra", but preferably not in a manner that destroys edit history.

Reason being that there are apparently 511 pages on Wikipedia containing the word Philharmonia, and the first 12 refer to musical groups that have the word in their name. I'm not seeing why the London one is so special, apart from probably being the first ones to use the word on its own, and thus having the privilege of usually being the group being referred to when the word is used on its own.

The reason about namespace and infobox being different is also valid.

Failing a move, a disambiguation page/link would be nice. 211.30.131.83 (talk) 20:39, 16 February 2008 (UTC)