Talk:Peter Grodin
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Most of the writing on Peter Grodin was POV and so reverted under WP:NPOV until such time as a proper formatted and established article can be created. - Count23 11:43, 13 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Redirect
Grodin was previously here and then transferred to the "tau'ri characters on atlantis" page. He doesn't belong there, he has had much more of a role in Atlantis then a footnote in another page. I'll be expanding this with more information in the next day or so and i dont think it should be redirected back without a merge vote. Andromeda, this means you since you transferred the original article 6 months ago WITHOUT a merge vote - Count23 14:16, 13 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Proposed Merger
- Strong Oppose - Peter Grodin played a significant role in the first season of Atlantis. Granted he was not a major character but he was directly responsible for destroying a wraith hive ship and appeared in numerous episodes in a support role not unlike Dr Zelenka in the first season. He appears in more episodes then Laura Cadman and Kate Heightmeyer and they both have their own pages. There is plenty of material to write about him and it should be left here. He had a more important role in the first season of Atlantis then Walter Harriman did in the first 5 seasons of SG-1. AfD concerns or not. - Count23 12:28, 15 March 2007 (UTC)
- Strongly in favour - Grodin played a very small role. He was in a more episodes perhaps, but he did nothing in them. His only major role is in his last episode. He wasn't more than a glorified errand boy for Weir. There's not much more to say about him. There's no reason for him to have his own page. --Andromeda 19:58, 15 March 2007 (UTC)
