Talk:Parasuicide
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Medicine. Please visit the project page for details or ask questions at the doctor's mess. |
| Start | This page has been rated as Start-Class on the quality assessment scale |
| Mid | This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the importance assessment scale |
 Portal |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Psychology, which collaborates on Psychology and related subjects on Wikipedia. To participate, help improve this article or visit the project page for details on the project.
|
||||||||
Contents |
[edit] Dubious
Should DSH really be called "suicide attempts"? Such strong statements definitely need citations.. --Kiwibird 20:06, 9 May 2006 (UTC)
See Suicide Section Suicide 7 and Suicide 7.1 for a better explanation of the differences between DSH (deliberate self-harm) and Parasuicide (suicide attempt).
"An important distinction has also been made (see Erwin Stengel, 'Suicide and Attempted Suicide') between those who kill themselves and did not mean to, and those who did not kill themselves but did mean to. Thus a 'Suicide' (noun) may either succeed or fail in his/her goal (i.e. succeed in killing himself/herself or not) and an 'Attempted Suicide' (noun) may either succeed or fail in his/her goal (e.g., succeed in 'making a cry for help' or fail and, in doing so, probably die)."
The writer cites Stengel in the article, but does not include it in the reference section. A quick search found the following info about Erwin Stengel Suicide & Attempted Suicide. 1964. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books Ltd., 1966.
Since I did not write the article and have no knowledge of Stengal's work, I don't feel comfortable adding it the reference section.
Clairemkelly 04:37, 3 January 2007 (UTC)I work in the areas of suicide, deliberate self-injury and attempted suicide and the term parasuicide is of no value. It is a term which is used to denote any kind of self-injurious behaviour regardless of intention and as such has no real value in psychological terminology.
In this article I believe that "suicide attempt" is a better title. Deliberate self-harm is a term which should be avoided, using instead self-injury or suicide attempt. Use of non-specific terms are not helpful in any way, particularly when a topic is as poorly understood as this one is.
I agree, self-harm is distinct: Self-harm is not meant to end in the person's death whereas suicide attempts are. That distinction does not appear to be applied in the article.Dogsdontknowimnotbacon 22:37, 31 August 2007 (UTC)
[edit] NPOV?
I agree with the above criticism and would add a question about POV. It seems that this article asserts hypotheses about the nature of the behavior without offering opposing viewpoints (i.e. the article rejects the possibility of attempted suicides' actually being suicide and merely states that they are acts of deliberate self-harm without evidence thereof). Aleta 06:48, 7 December 2006 (UTC) Aleta
[edit] Parasuicide is more of a histoirical term now
Parasuicide was used in mental health but was phased out in the 1990s as the idea was artificial - there is often no clearcut boundary between high risk and low risk attempts and many people who exhibit low risk can infact end up killing themselves.
Dismissing attempts of low perceived lethality is dangerous. In reality all attempts are care-eliciting gestures of some sort. cheers Cas Liber 20:54, 30 December 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Is self-harm/self-injury even relevant?
Firstly: self-harm/self-injury != suicide attempt
Now that's out of the way...
"Those who attempt to harm themselves are, as a group, quite different from those who actually die from suicide."
Those who attempt to harm themselves are, as a group, very often quite different from those who even attempt suicide, or are suicidal.
"Although they [people who self-harm/self-injure] are rarely physically ill, they are considered psychiatrically unstable."
Depending on your definition of "psychiatrically unstable", this sentence almost certainly not true.
"Individuals under these stresses become anxious and depressed and then, usually in reaction to crisis, be it considered small or huge to others, they attempt to harm themselves."
The reasons people self-harm/self-injure are so varied, one cannot make a generalisation like this.
"Self-harm may also result from an inner conflict between the desire to end life and to continue living."
Can we please avoid saying self-harm/self-injury is linked to suicide like this? Statistically, yes, there are links between the two, but the feelings and motivations behind them are often very different; suicide is wanting to end one's life, self-harm/self-injury is often a coping mechanism, a way to keep on living.
i agree in many ways. personally, self-harm is at one end of a spectrum, suicide ideation at the other. self-harm is my mechanism for coping - inflicting pain on myself as a means of distracting my attention away from another type of pain - note the general idea of wanting to feel a certain type of pain over another type of pain. contrast this with episodes of suicidal ideation, when it seems that no coping mechanism can help. the goal becomes to eliminate pain (in all its forms) by terminating my life - the pain involved in the process of terminating my life becomes a consequence of the goal - note the careful planning and selection of a suicide method, driven by the general desire for a "quick and painless" death.
it's a thin line between suicide and parasuicide. lack of adequate planning due to a hurried decision made in an impulsive suicidal state, not caring about whether the suicide attempt works or not, surviving a suicide attempt that would ordinarily have worked - whatever the reason for the distinction between suicide and parasuicide, the attempter is likely to have accepted death (the end of all pain) as a possible outcome, to some degree. choosing death and flirting with death both have death as a possible "solution" to pain... this is not always the case with self-harm (a fairly broad, blanket term) 195.189.142.198 05:38, 23 June 2007 (UTC)Thinkerboy
- As a very uninterested observer, the article seems to be saying to me that suicide attempts that don't succeed are invariably forms of attention-getting. Just because somebody's not very good at killing themselves doesn't mean they were doing it for attention. Sometimes people simply don't succeed in what they're attempting, like poor Jerry Hadley today. --Charlene 22:01, 11 July 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Neutrality on Suicide Generally
"Regardless of the intention of the parasuicide, it must be treated seriously, due to the risk of future suicide attempts by these individuals."
This statement is particularly troubling, in my opinion. The very statement implies the belief that suicides should be prevented which, while it may be a commonly held position, does take a stance on the issue, rather than maintaining the neutrality that Wikipedia intends to maintain. While the entire statement need not necessarily be struck from the article, it certainly at least needs revision, to maintain neutrality. -- Rev. S. Alexander Normandy 20:30, 4 October 2007 (UTC)
[edit] WikiProject class rating
This article was automatically assessed because at least one WikiProject had rated the article as stub, and the rating on other projects was brought up to Stub class. BetacommandBot 16:30, 10 November 2007 (UTC)
