Talk:Modoc traditional narratives

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

i question the necessity of this article. all it is, is a bibliography. without all of the publication titles this article is tiny and lackling in useful inmformation. i have no knowledge of this topic so i would suggest that if someone does, get on this article. --Tainter 17:15, 8 December 2006 (UTC)

This article is one in a series that present information on the traditional narratives of all the Native California groups. I think that the listings of documentary sources for these narratives (not just bibliographies, but with additional information annotated to them) are valuable. The text portion is indeed very brief, and it may be augmented later. However, a problem that plagues many of the Wikipedia articles on "mythology" is that they contain too much hasty generalization by enthusiastic contributors who understand very little about the subject and offer no evidence or citations to back up their personal interpretations.RhymeNotStutter 02:57, 9 December 2006 (UTC)

Tainter: If you have no constructive suggestions to make, please refrain from vandalizing the page. RhymeNotStutter 22:57, 9 December 2006 (UTC)