Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2008-04-07 Jihad Watch

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Wikipedia Mediation Cabal

Article: Jihad Watch State: Closed Requested By: SmithBlue Other Parties: thestick SmithBlue Yahel Guhan CormHamster Mediated By: Vassyana (talk · contribs) Comments: Mediation stale. Limited to no participation. Filing requests for comment to draw outside opinions and more participation.

Contents 1 Request details 1.1 Who are the involved parties? 1.2 What's going on? 1.3 What would you like to change about that? 2 Mediator notes 3 Administrative notes 4 Discussion

[edit] Request details

[edit] Who are the involved parties?

SmithBlue , Yahel Guhan , thestick , CormHamster , Sennen goroshi , Bless_sins, others?

[edit] What's going on?

No consensus on inclusion/exclusion of Jihad Watch in/from Category:AntiMuslim sentiment" Period of apparent edit-warring stopped some 2 weeks ago. Issue unresolved.

[edit] What would you like to change about that?

Consensus view to emerge and fuller understanding of WP policies and WP dispute resolution mechanisms for editors involved.

[edit] Mediator notes

[edit] Administrative notes

[edit] Discussion

Prefer discussion on article talk page. Editors not presently part of mediation may wish to contribute. SmithBlue (talk) 06:40, 7 April 2008 (UTC)