Talk:Max Sterling

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Stop with the Macross already

Oppose merge - I am removing all merge suggestions for any Robotech character involved. I agree that Robotech character descriptions should include links to any character descriptions from the original source material. After all, they do share the animation. However, the fact is that Robotech as a story concept and development is completely different from its source material. It's time to end the confusion between them. Kinglehr 02:59, 4 November 2007 (UTC)Kinglehr

I agree that the original Macross version and the Robotech remake should be kept separate, but the fact is that Robotech as a story concept and development is not completey different from its source material. To say otherwise is to abuse the definition of the word "completely." Robotech is different, but it's still based on the source material and not a "completely" different story.1-54-24 (talk) 22:19, 23 December 2007 (UTC)

Don't unilaterally make sweeping changes like this. See WP:CON. The purpose of the mergeto templtes is discussion of a merge, not a demand of merge. Granted there's been little interest in the issue for a long time, but out of what discussion has occured, there's been no consensus. Removing the template only further hinders this effort, because it prevents people from gathering on one talk page. Also, the discussion wasn't actually taking place on said talk page until just yesterday, because it had been deleted (since the corresponding article didn't yet exist), but I had it restored when I created the page TheBilly (talk) 22:16, 23 December 2007 (UTC)