User talk:Matarael

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Images

Hi Matarael, would you have any pictures of the World Centre that you have taken yourself that you could upload at commons.wikimedia.org on a free license? Regards, -- Jeff3000 04:35, 21 November 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Egyptian Identification Card Controversy

Hello, in an effort to get the Egyptian Identification Card Controversy, which you have been contributing to, upto Wikipidia standards I've started a major cleanup of the page. I've placed many {{fact}} tags in the text which show up like ^{[citation needed]}. If you could help by finding sources for those statements it would be great. Note that the sources have to verifiable and in reliable sources; blogs, personal websites and self-published resources are not considered reliable. Also, using third-party sources, (i.e. not Baha'i sources) would be preferable. Thanks, -- Jeff3000 19:45, 28 December 2006 (UTC)

Hey Matareal,

Let me refer you to Meno25, a fellow contributer to WikiProject Egypt. This user was the one who rated Egyptian Identification Card Controversy as B-class in WikiProject Egypt, and I am sure that he would be willing to let you know why. I merely added this article to the project. Happy New Year!

--Yitzhak1995 20:10, 1 January 2007 (UTC)

Here I am! First of all I would like to thank you for the polite language you use. You are very polite. Second, this article is rated as B. The next rating is GA. Please see Wikipedia:Good articles and Wikipedia:Good articles/Candidates. GA rating is complex. First you have to ask for a peer review, then the article will be reviewed by one or more Wikipedians. (What I did was just leaving minor comments not a full review.) After that an administrator will revise every thing and award the article the GA status. However, I don't recommend that you nominate it now because the article is short. I love the neutral language of this article and the references section but the problem here is lack of content. You need to expand the article by adding more details. However, you did a great job. Cheers.

--Meno25 09:39, 6 January 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Citing Sources

Really appreciate your cleaning up Bahá'í World Centre. One comment. It is really important that we provide sources and notes, the more the better. Non-Baha'i sources are preferable, but we sometimes have to make do with what's at hand. This helps keep articles in line with various WP policies like WP:NPOV, WP:V & WP:A. It does make the work harder, but it makes the work product much better. Regards, MARussellPESE 03:26, 1 July 2007 (UTC)