Talk:List of handgun cartridges

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is within the scope of the WikiProject Firearms; If you would like to join us, please visit the project page where you can find a list of open tasks. If you have any questions, please consult the FAQ.
??? This article has not yet received a rating on the quality scale.

[edit] Caliber pages Stubs?

These are all very good articles, but since most of these pages are short, wouldn't it be more effective to have all of them merged into single pages? This could be applied to the 9mm cartridges, and the .22's for starters, since there are so many variants of those specific ammunition types. An added bonus is that people who were unfamiliar with the specific types wouldn't be confused by an unecessary disambiguation page.GameJunkieJim 13:59, 12 May 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Definition of hand gun cartridge?

Whats the definition to be used on this page? Its not stated. If a cartridge was first made for one or another then it should be listed as first one or both?. Or should now the 45/70 has been in a hand gun it should listed as a pistol cartridge? Then both lists should just be combined as there will be examples or nearly every one in the other. So how is it decided if it belongs in both lists? The makes desciption of the cartridge when first released, then if not description was it forst commercially made in pistol or rifle as the decider?--Big5Hunter 08:58, 5 October 2007 (UTC)

A reference text such as "Cartridges of the World" would be a good start. Let's look at your removals:
  • .22 Long Rifle and .22 WMR are both widely popular handgun chamberings. These can both be considered as dual use cartridges. It is not uncommon to see either of these listed in the handgun section of ammunition catalogs.
  • .22 Remington Jet was first chambered in the S&W Model 53 revolver. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • .221 Remington Fireball was first chambered in the Remington XP100 handgun. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • .256 Winchester Magnum was designed for revolvers. None were released, but it was introduced in the Ruger Hawkeye pistol. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • 7mm Bench Rest Remington was introduced in the Remington XP100 handgun. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • 7.65 mm Mannlicher was introduced in the Mannlicher Model 1900 pistol. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • .32 H&R Magnum was introduced in H&R and Charter Arms revolvers. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.
  • .32-20 Winchester is a dual use cartridge. It has been chambered in revolvers by both Colt and S&W. It has not been uncommon to see this listed in the handgun section of ammunition catalogs.
  • .44-40 Winchester is a dual use cartridge. It has been chambered in revolvers by both Colt and S&W. It has been chambered in revolvers by both Colt and S&W. It has not been uncommon to see this listed in the handgun section of ammunition catalogs.
  • .50 Remington was introduced with the Remington Model 1867 Navy pistol, and later used in the Model 1871 pistol by the US Army. Listed in COTW as a handgun cartridge.

D.E. Watters 16:04, 5 October 2007 (UTC)