Talk:List of classical guitar makers

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

It seems to me that this article is redundant. The guitar makers here are all luthiers, so why not have them in that article? Is the purpose of this article to segregate classical guitar makers and give them a separate list? If so, shouldn't this list just be a subset of those who are classical guitar makers obtained from the luthiers list?

Also, it seems this list attracts those who would like to be listed, and since Wikipedia is not a directory, the article seems counterproductive.

Please advise.Mbartruff 23:13, 4 November 2006 (UTC)

I'm a bit inclined to agree, and I'm very puzzled by the link to Nicholas Scott, who appears to be an MP without any very evident interest in guitars. I think someone has probably linked to the wrong person - I wonder if it would be sensible to just take it out? Let's see if there's a response to this first. 139.184.30.136 (talk) 15:16, 27 May 2008 (UTC)