User talk:Kentino

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Feel free to ask me a question or let me know if a contribution I made needed editing or removal.

[edit] Golf Tournaments

You are most gracious. In reality, I am not really a formal member of the golf project and perhaps should not have been as quick as I was to remove your information (I am just willful like that). The problem I see with your methodology is that the precise number is not always relevant. As you note, there are certain "stock" numbers, but for an event like the Mercedes, the field size isn't pre-set; it's as many golfers as qualify under the rules. Even those events with set field sizes will deviate from that with sponsors exemptions, etc. Going by the raw number of entrants in the tournament doesn't say much about the event; it'd be more valuable to track down the "intrinsic" number of players assigned to each event, if there is one (such as those events that have "144" players in them, even if exactly 144 don't actually tee it up in a given year). This is something that people who know more about the PGA Tour than me ought to do; I would suggest Tewapack in particular, as it was him (I think) that did the real yeoman's work of putting all the historical PGA Tour schedules for historic seasons on the site. A truly valuable contribution. I think that your proposal of putting that figure on the article page for each event in its infobox is the best approach once there is some consensus as to what that number ought to be for each tournament. MrArticleOne (talk) 02:48, 5 March 2008 (UTC)

[edit] Field sizes

I think field size would be a useful addition to the tournament infoboxes. I don't know of any source that states the field size in advance for all tournaments but take a look at User:Tewapack/Sandbox2 for the fields since 2005. Only a few of the fields vary in size and they have specific qualification critera. Also see [1] for the weekly PGA Tour newsletter that states the field size for that weeks event.Tewapack (talk) 05:05, 6 March 2008 (UTC)