Judge Mathis

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Judge Mathis
Format	Court
Starring	Greg Mathis
Country of origin	United States
Production
Running time	60 minutes (with commercials)
Broadcast
Original channel	Syndicated
Original run	1999 – present
External links
Official website
IMDb profile

Judge Mathis is a syndicated television legal reality show produced originally by Black Pearl Productions. In 2007, it entered its ninth season produced by And Syndicated Productions and Telepictures.^[1] It is taped at NBC Tower in Chicago, but includes cases and litigants from other U.S. jurisdictions. The show is broadcast five days a week in every U.S. state (except New Hampshire and Delaware), Puerto Rico and in Canada through OMNI Television.^[2]^[3] The show has been on the air since 1999, and has taped over 1000 episodes.^[4]

[edit] Show format

In the series retired Superior Court judge of Michigan's 36th District Court Greg Mathis presides over disputes between plaintiffs and defendants. The cases are classified as tort law, civil disputes with a maximum $5,000 claim, a typical amount for small claims court cases. There are typically 4 cases presented in each hour-long episode. The show solicits litigants with real cases before the court, and each litigant must enter into a legally binding agreement to be held under the judgment. The producers of the show select cases, and it appears that Mathis does not have prior knowledge of the case besides reading typical material fact claims filed with a small claims court. Thus like the typical small claims court, the plaintiff has the burden of proof and must argue his/her case before the Judge and answer any questions directed to him/her. Typically, Mathis asks for documents that verify a claim, and upon final judgment he may briefly explain the legal principle guiding his decision, especially if his ruling is based on a particular state's law. The rulings conform to the laws of the state where the case was originally filed. Like most small claims court procedure, the parties before him cannot cross examine each other and must speak only to the bench. However, unlike most small claims court judges, Mathis occasionally retires to his chamber to deliberate and investigate a litigant's evidence before crafting his decision.

[edit] Show style

Like many TV judge shows, only the bailiff, besides the judge, is a recurring character. The first bailiff on the series, Brendan Anthony Moran, died on December 28, 2002, after an apparent suicide^{[citation needed]}. Since then, Judge Mathis has had two bailiffs. The current bailiff is Doyle Devereux. Prior to the Judge Mathis show he starred as a tuxedo salesman in the 1991 John Candy movie Only the Lonely. Bailiff Doyle often acts as a comic relief for the show, interjecting lighthearted observations about the litigants or their cases. Among the recurring humorous motifs, both Doyle and Mathis frequently insinuate that Doyle enjoys smoking marijuana and has an eye for pretty women. The bailiff also oversees the parties after the judgment in the studio court room hallway, where litigants respond on camera to Judge Mathis' ruling.

More so than other TV judges, Mathis is full of fun while on the bench. Unlike other legal shows, particularly Judge Judy, Mathis tolerates informal digressions and is more laid-back while on the bench; in fact, some petitioners blurt out statements in the heat of the moment that contradict their own sworn testimony or otherwise undermine their cases while Judge Mathis listens with bemusement and laughter. Judge Mathis also often entertains longwinded, mean-spirited personal asides by one litigant about the other (even when such testimony bears no relevance to the case), but then allows the defamed party equal time to respond in kind. Often, Judge Mathis will crack jokes about the whole argument and is usually seen making his audience laugh. He also ridicules the litigants. In the course of adjudicating, litigants often yell at each other, sometimes for extended periods of time; however, Judge Mathis will not tolerate disrespect and will dismiss cases if litigants demean or use profane language directed towards himself or the party before him.

Aspiring singers and rappers who appear on the show may even be granted a moment to showcase their talents from the lectern. Due to the popularity of the show and its long run on television, parties before the judge often profess personal fondness for Mathis, who tolerates the kind words gracefully, but will not let them affect his decisions. In recent years, the show has began to conduct paternity testing in disputes about child custody, and drug testing in applicable cases. Mathis often offers or compels drug treatment and family counseling for parties.