Talk:John Whitmer Historical Association
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
My general sense is that this is a self-promotion piece. But otherwise it is good because it is factual and non-biased. Jgardner 17:28, 17 Jun 2005 (UTC)
[edit] LDS Peer Review
Someone listed this on WP:LDS Peer Review a LONG time ago, and so I've gotten around to finally peer reviewing it. I've been incredibly scrutinizing on this article, so don't feel like I'm being a bad guy - I'm just reviewing it with the same scrutiny as I would a normal peer review, or a FAC. I did a major rewrite of it, but there were some questions I still had. I realize that many of these will probably remained unanswered without original research, but here it is. Questions:
- How, and how often, are Presidents chosen?
Once a year
- Do their founding goals still stand as their current goals? If they are current goals, list them somewhere besides history.
- Is there anything else of signifcance at their annual conferences?
- Who has been the "keynote speaker"? Why are they "keynote"?
- The president is "Newell G. Bringhurst", and it says he is "author and editor of numerous books, including..." How many books is numerous? Why are the ones mentioned noteworthy? Has he done anything else noteworthy? What is his profession? Why was he chosen as president?
I am going to take it off of LDS Peer Review. If anyone wants another (or more) peer review, feel free to re-list it, preferrably with a detailed explanation of what focus you want i nthe Peer Review. --Trevdna 18:24, 12 January 2006 (UTC)
