John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 The factual accuracy of this article is disputed.
Please see the relevant discussion on the talk page. (March 2008)
The 1st Earl of Clare.
The 1st Earl of Clare.

John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare (c.1749 near Dublin –28 January 1802 in Dublin), was the son of John FitzGibbon and his wife Isabella Grove, daughter of John Grove, of Ballyhimmock, County Cork, Ireland. FitzGibbon, later known as Earl of Clare or Lord Clare, was Attorney-General for Ireland in 1783, then Lord Chancellor of Ireland in 1789, (in which capacity he was first promoted to the Irish peerage). He was a controversial figure in Irish history, being described variously as a Protestant hardliner, a staunch anti-Catholic, and an early supporter of Union with England (which finally happened shortly before his death). He is said to have been an early opponent of measures for Catholic political relief (meaning the removal of some or all legal disabilities against Catholics) in both Ireland and Great Britain, and may have been the first to suggest to George III that the King would violate his coronation oath if he consented to the admission of Catholics to Parliament.

FitzGibbon entered the Irish House of Commons in 1778 as Member for Trinity College, Dublin, and was appointed Attorney General in 1783. When appointed Lord Chancellor for Ireland in 1789, he was granted his first peerage as Baron FitzGibbon, of Lower Connello in the County of Limerick, in the Peerage of Ireland that year. This did not entitle him to a seat in the British House of Lords, only in the Irish House of Lords. His later promotions came mostly in the Peerage of Ireland, being advanced to a Viscountcy (1793) and the Earldom of Clare in 1795. He finally achieved a seat in the British House of Lords in 1799 when created Baron FitzGibbon, of Sidbury in the County of Devon, in the Peerage of Great Britain.

Contents

[edit] FitzGibbon as Lord Chancellor

John FitzGibbon, first Earl of Clare was a renowned champion of the Protestant Ascendancy and an opponent of Catholic emancipation. He despised the independent constitution of 1782, He was also personally and politically opposed to the Irish politician Henry Grattan who urged a moderate course in the Irish Parliament, and was responsible for defeating Grattan's efforts to reform the Irish land tithe system (1787-1789) under which millions of Irish Catholics (and all non-Anglicans) were forced to financially support the minority Anglican Church of Ireland. These were not fully repealed until 1869, (when the Church of Ireland was finally disestablished), although Irish tithes were commuted after the Tithe War (1831-1836).

FitzGibbon opposed the Catholic Relief Act of 1793 personally, but apparently recommended its acceptance (Although he opposed the act personally he recommended its acceptance in the House of Lords) of 1793, being forced out of necessity when that Act had been recommended to the Irish Executive by the British Cabinet (led by William Pitt the Younger). At the same time, FitzGibbon apparently denounced the policy this Act embodied, so it is probably safe to say that FitzGibbon's own beliefs and principles conflicted with his obligations as a member of the Irish executive of the time.

FitzGibbon's role in the recall, soon after his arrival, of the popular pro Catholic Emancipation Lord Lieutenant, Lord Fitzwilliam is debatable. Although FitzGibbon was probably politically opposed to the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, Fitzwilliam was apparently recalled, because of his own independent actions. Fitzwilliam was known to be friendly to the Ponsonby family (he was married to one of their daughters), and was generally a Liberal. His close association with and patronage of Irish Whigs led by Grattan and Ponsonby during his short tenure, along with his alleged support of an immediate effort to secure Catholic emancipation in a manner not authorized by the British cabinet is probably what led to his recall. Thus, if any is to blame in the short-lived 'Fitzwilliam episode' it is the great Irish politician Henry Grattan and the Ponsonby brothers - presumably [William Ponsonby], later Lord Imokilly and his brother John Ponsonby -- not to mention Lord Fitzwilliam himself. Irish nationalists at the time and later naturally saw things very differently and blamed hardline Protestants such as FitzGibbon.

Ironically, Irish Catholics and FitzGibbon agreed on one point apparently - Irish political and economic union with Great Britain (which eventually took place in 1801). Pitt had wanted Union with Ireland concomitantly with Catholic emancipation, commutation of tithes, and the endowment of the Irish Catholic priesthood. Union was opposed by most hardline Irish Protestants, although not all. FitzGibbon had been a strong supporter of Union since 1793, but refused to have Catholic emancipation with the Union. In the end, FitzGibbon's views won out, leading to the Union of Ireland with Great Britain to form the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland without any privileges for Ireland's Catholic majority (or for that matter, Catholics in the rest of the Kingdom). FitzGibbon later claimed that he had been duped by the way in which the Act was passed (by the new Viceroy Lord Cornwallis promising reforms to Irish Catholics), and was bitterly opposed to any concessions during the short remainder of his life.

[edit] FitzGibbon as Lord Chancellor in the Irish Rebellion of 1798

FitzGibbon's role as Lord Chancellor of Ireland during the period of the 1798 rebellion is questionable. According to some, he supported a hardline policy which used torture, murder and massacre to crush the rebellion[citation needed], or that as Lord Chancellor, he had considerable influence on military affairs, and that martial law could not have been imposed without his consent. Others allege that as Lord chancellor, he had no say in military affairs and the Encyclopedia Britannica states that he was "neither cruel nor immoderate and was inclined to mercy when dealing with individuals" , however the same source also states that "(Fitzgibbon).. was a powerful supporter of a repressive policy toward Irish Catholics". Fitzgibbon's former side was displayed by sparing the lives of the captured United Irish leaders, 'State prisoners', in return for their confession of complicity and provision of information relating to the planning of the rebellion. However, this willingness of the prisoners to partake of the agreement was spurred by the execution of the brothers John and Henry Sheares on July 14, 1798.

In contrast to the leniency shown to the largely upper class leadership, the full weight of military repression was inflicted upon the common people throughout the years 1797-98 with untold thousands suffering imprisonment, torture, transportation and death. Fitzgibbon was inclined to show no mercy to unrepentant rebels and in October 1798 he expressed his disgust upon the capture of Wolfe Tone that he had been granted a trial and his belief that Tone should have been hanged as soon as he set foot on land.[1]

He was quick to recognise that sectarianism was a useful ally to divide the rebels and prevent the United Irishmen achieving their goal of uniting Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter, writing in June 1798; "In the North nothing will keep the rebels quiet but the conviction that where treason has broken out the rebellion is merely popish".[2]

Another anecdote is to the effect of his callousness. Supposedly, upon being informed during a debate in the Irish Parliament that innocent as well as guilty were suffering atrocities during the repression, FitzGibbon replied "Well suppose it were so..", his callous reply purportedly shocking William Pitt.[3]

[edit] FitzGibbon as a Landlord

FitzGibbon, or Clare, was noted by some as a good, improving landlord to both his Protestant and Catholic tenants.[citation needed] Some claim that the tenants of his Mountshannon estate called him "Black Jack" FitzGibbon.[citation needed] There is however no evidence to support this claim, although there is little to no evidence on his dealings as a landlord. Irish nationalists and others point out that while he might have been interested in the welfare of his own tenants on his own estate, he treated other Irish Catholics very differently. Without further evidence, FitzGibbon's role as a Protestant landowner in mainly Catholic Ireland is of little importance against his known dealings as Lord Chancellor.

[edit] Apocryphal story about his funeral

Lord Clare died at home, 6 Ely Place, near St. Stephen's Green, Dublin on 28th January 1802 and was buried in St. Peter's Churchyard. A hero to Protestant hardliners, but despised by the majority Catholic population, his funeral cortege was the cause of a riot and there is a widespread story that, with a typical Irish sense of humour and a 19th. century lack of appreciation of cats, a number of dead cats were thrown at his coffin as it departed his residence in Ely Place. [4]

[edit] Summary

FitzGibbon appears to have made little mark in British political history, as compared to Irish parliamentary history. His adversary Henry Grattan and the aristocratic rebel Lord Edward FitzGerald (with the other rebels of 1798) are better remembered (or at least researched on the Internet!). FitzGibbon was apparently a hardline Protestant, a landlord and a member of the Protestant Ascendancy, who naturally supported those political measures that would preserve Protestant domination of Ireland and the continued suppression of the numerically dominant Catholics in Ireland. He won his point in 1801 and its immediate aftermath, when the Irish Parliament was dissolved and Union with Great Britain was achieved - without any concessions to Catholics. In the long run, his views lost out, as subsequent British Cabinets were forced to concede full rights to Catholics in 1829 (while imposing new voting restrictions in Ireland and thus disenfranchising poorer Catholics). The Union with Great Britain, so bitterly opposed by Henry Grattan, was eventually dissolved partially more than a century later.

FitzGibbon's most significant achievement (historically speaking) was probably his convincing King George III that any concessions to Roman Catholics, whether in Great Britain or in Ireland, would mean that the King was violating his Coronation Oath. Thus, the King and his second son became staunch opponents of pro-Emanicipation measures, which had to wait until both had died. In thus convincing the King (probably between 1793 and 1801), FitzGibbon's policy of repression towards Irish Catholics achieved its finest hour; in doing so, he also defeated all that Grattan and his party had worked to obtain. Furthermore, he also brought about Pitt's downfall, because Pitt had staked his own reputation on obtaining Catholic emancipation concurrently with the Act of Union. No other British Prime Minister would make such efforts for a long time. FitzGibbon thus had a negative role not only in Irish parliamentary and political history, but also in British political history.

By negating all of Grattan's efforts 1787-1789 and those of Pitt in the late 1790s to 1801, FitzGibbon allowed conditions to develop that would benefit sectarian leaders and political philosophies from both religious communities. It is unclear if FitzGibbon's support of Grattan, or support for Pitt's proposals would have made much difference, given that many hardline Protestants probably felt the same way as FitzGibbon. Furthermore, the British Cabinet (not to mention the Royal Family, then far more influential politically) was itself divided on the issue for most of the period. But just as Catholic Emancipation was brought about by a Tory Prime Minister in 1829, or substantial voting reforms brought about by Disraeli and the Conservatives, thus winning support from a crucial minority of those originally opposed to either, the support of a prominent hardline Protestant leader for Catholic Emancipation might have made all the difference to Irish history.

[edit] Titles

All titles became extinct with the death of his younger son Richard Hobart FitzGibbon, 3rd and last Earl of Clare, on 10 January 1864.

[edit] References

  1. ^ Letter to William Eden, 1st Baron Auckland, 26 October 1798.
  2. ^ Letter to Privy Council, 4 June 1798
  3. ^ from "The Irish Act of Union" - Patrick M. Geoghegan (2001)
  4. ^ "from The once great houses of Ireland" Duncan McLaren Little,Brown &Co.1980

[edit] Sources

  • "The Irish Act of Union" - Patrick M. Geoghegan (2001)
  • "A Volley of Execrations: the letters and papers of John Fitzgibbon, earl of Clare, 1772-1802", edited by D.A. Fleming and A.P.W. Malcomson. (2004)
  • Oxford Dictionary of National Biography

[edit] External links

Political offices
Preceded by
Unknown		 Attorney General for Ireland
1783 – 1789		 Succeeded by
Unknown
In commission
Title last held by
The Viscount Lifford		 Lord Chancellor of Ireland
1789 – 1802		 Succeeded by
John Freeman-Mitford
Parliament of Ireland
Preceded by
Richard Hely-Hutchinson		 Member for Trinity College, Dublin
1778 – 1783		 Succeeded by
Arthur Browne
Preceded by
Unknown		 Member for Kilmallock
1783 – 1789		 Succeeded by
Unknown
Peerage of Ireland
New creation Earl of Clare
3rd creation
1795 – 1802		 Succeeded by
John FitzGibbon
Viscount FitzGibbon
1793 – 1802
Baron FitzGibbon
(of Lower Connello)
1789 – 1802
Peerage of Great Britain
New creation Baron FitzGibbon
(of Sidbury)
1799 – 1802		 Succeeded by
John FitzGibbon