James Hanratty

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

James Hanratty

Hanratty went to Kingsbury High School, Brent, He lived on Sycamore Grove.
Born October 4, 1936(1936-10-04)
Bromley, Kent, England
Died April 4, 1962 (aged 25)
Bedford Prison, Bedford, Bedfordshire, England
Cause of death Executed (hanging)
Nationality British
Known for "A6 murder"

James Hanratty (born October 4, 1936 in Bromley, Kent, England;[1] died April 4, 1962 in Bedford Prison, Bedford, Bedfordshire, England[2]) was the eighth to last person in Britain to be hanged for murder[citation needed] after being convicted of carrying out the notorious 1961 "A6 murder". The guilt of the later convicts was never in doubt, but Hanratty's guilt has been disputed. [3] Hanratty was a professional car thief, convicted of the murder of Michael Gregsten at Deadman's Hill on the A6, near the village of Clophill, [4] Bedfordshire, England, on August 22, 1961. Further, Gregsten's companion Valerie Storie was raped and shot non-fatally during the incident. Charges on these additional crimes were kept in reserve.

In his book, Hanratty: The Final Verdict (1997) Macmillan ISBN 0-333-71015-0, Bob Woffinden incorrectly states that Hanratty's full name was James Francis Hanratty. This was the name of his father, Hanratty himself had no middle name.

The case was a cause célèbre for opponents of the death penalty, who maintained that Hanratty was innocent and sought to draw attention to evidence that would cast doubt on the validity of his conviction. However, following an appeal by his family, modern testing of DNA from his exhumed corpse and members of his family convinced Court of Appeal judges in 2002 that his guilt was proved "beyond doubt". [5]

Contents

[edit] The Murder

Michael Gregsten was a scientist at the Road Research Laboratory at Slough. Valerie Storie was an assistant at the same laboratory, and was having an affair with Gregsten, although this did not become public knowledge until much later. Michael Gregsten's body was discovered in the lay-by on the A6 at Deadman's Hill at about 6:30 on 23 August 1961. Valerie Storie was lying next to him semi-conscious. The evening after the murder, Michael Gregsten's grey 1956 Morris Minor was found abandoned behind Redbridge tube station in London.

[edit] Witness Testimony of Valerie Storie

On Tuesday, 22 August 1961, Gregsten and Storie were sitting in his car in a cornfield at Dorney Reach in Berkshire when someone tapped on the car window. Gregsten wound it down. A large black revolver was thrust into his face, and a cockney voice said, "This is a hold-up, I am a desperate man, I have been on the run for four months. If you do as I tell you, you will be all right." The man got in the car and told Gregsten to drive further into the field, then stop. The man then kept them there for two hours, with a constant stream of nagging, mindless chatter. At 23:30, the man said he wanted food, and told Gregsten to start driving. They drove around the suburbs of North London, apparently aimlessly. The gunman knew the Bear Hotel, Maidenhead. The car was ordered to stop at a milk vending machine, then Gregsten was sent into a shop to buy cigarettes, then stop at a petrol station for more fuel. Although Gregsten and Storie offered to give him all their money and the car, the man seemed to have no plan and seemed to want them to stay with him.

The journey continued along the A5 through St Albans, which the gunman mistakenly insisted was Watford, before joining the A6. At about 01:30, the car was on the A6, travelling south, when the man said he wanted a 'kip' (sleep). Twice he told Gregsten to turn off the road and then changed his mind, and the car returned to the A6. At Deadman's Hill the man ordered Gregsten to pull into a layby. He at first refused, but the man became aggressive and threatened them with the gun. The man said he wanted to sleep, but said he would have to tie them up. Storie and Gregsten pleaded with him not to shoot them. The man tied Storie's hands behind her back with Gregsten's tie and then saw a bag in the rear of the car with some rope. He told Gregsten to pass the bag but, as Gregsten moved, there were two shots. Gregsten was hit twice in the head and died more or less instantly. According to Storie's testimony, when she asked the gunman why he had shot Gregsten he replied that Gregsten had frightened him by turning too quickly.

After a short while, he ordered Storie into the back, over Gregsten's body, and raped her, then forced her to drag Gregsten's body out of the car. The man then told Storie to show him how to drive the car. It was clear the man either had not driven before or at least was unfamiliar with this model of car, as he did not know how to start it or how to use the pedals or gears properly. This failing, he then ordered Storie out of the car and next to Gregsten's body. She pleaded for her life, and then took a pound note from her pocket and screamed, "Here, take this, take the car and go." The man then emptied the gun at Storie in the darkness. Of approximately seven bullets fired, five hit her body (causing injuries that were to paralyse her permanently from the waist down). She slumped down next to Gregsten, and pretended to be dead. Valerie Storie then heard the man drive off with much crashing of gears, and lay there petrified, finally passing out three hours later. She was discovered by a farm labourer, Sydney Burton, at 06:45 next morning. He ran down the road and summoned John Kerr, a student occupied with taking a road census. Kerr flagged down two cars, shouting at them to get an ambulance.

[edit] The Investigation

The first policemen on the scene was handed a piece of paper, a census form. Kerr had written down Valerie Storie's gasped account of what she recalled at that moment. The document was never seen again. She gave another statement to the police later that morning, just before she underwent surgery in Bedford Hospital. Almost at once, the evidence began to throw up anomalies. Valerie recalled what the man has said about being on the run for four months, yet he was immaculately dressed in a dark three-piece suit and with well-shone shoes. Also, there appeared to be a complete lack of motive. On 23 August Audrey Willis was threatened in her home in Knebworth by a gunman with a long thin face and sallow complexion aged about 30. Incredibly he repeated this on 2 April 1962 claiming to be the A6 murderer.

The gun was then recovered on the evening of 24 August, under the back seat of a 36A London bus, fully loaded and wiped clean of fingerprints. There was also a handkerchief found with the gun which was to provide DNA evidence many years later. The police put out an appeal to boarding-house keepers to report any strange or suspicious guests. One hotel owner reported a man who had locked himself in his room for five days after the murder, and the police picked him up, and he said his name was Frederick Durrant, but this turned out to be false and he was actually called Peter Alphon. He claimed he had spent the evening of 22 August with his mother, and the following night in a scruffy hotel in Maida Vale called the 'Vienna'. The police quickly confirmed this[citation needed] and Alphon was released. On 29 August, Valerie Storie (who was paralysed from the waist down from her injuries) and another witness, Edward Blackall, who had seen the driver of the Morris Minor, compiled an Identikit picture which was then released. However, two days later, she gave a different description to police.

Meike Dalal was attacked in her home in Richmond, Surrey, on 7 September by a man claiming to be the A6 murderer (whom she identified as Alphon in an identity parade on 23 September). The investigation stalled then until 11 September, when the owner of the Vienna Hotel, Maida Vale, found two cartridge cases in the guest basement bedroom, which were matched to the bullets that killed Gregsten and also matched the ones in the gun found on the bus. The owner, William Nudds, made a statement to police naming the last occupant of the room as James Ryan. At the trial Nudds also stated that the man, upon leaving, had asked the way to a bus stop for a 36A bus, though his statement to police had merely mentioned the 36 bus. Nudds' statement also said that Alphon had stayed in the hotel as he claimed, but had stayed in his room, room 6, all night The police raided the hotel, and questioned Nudds again, who then changed his story, claiming that Alphon had in fact been in the basement and Ryan in room 6, but then the two had swapped rooms during the night. Nudds also now said that Alphon had left 'calm and composed'.

The police then took the unusual step of publicly naming Alphon as the murder suspect. Alphon subsequently turned himself in, and was subjected to an intensive interrogation. Valerie Storie failed to pick him out of an identity parade, and he was released four days later. During the four days he was held on the charge of assaulting Meike Dalal, he is recorded by PC Ian Thomson as saying "there can't have been any fingerprints in the car otherwise mine would have given me away". Police went back to Nudds, the hotel owner, who now said that his second statement was a lie, and his first statement, implicating Ryan, was in fact true. His reason for lying was that he had seen that Alphon was the police's prime suspect and wanted to assist their case. After some investigation, Ryan turned out to be James Hanratty, a petty car thief and robber, who in fact was facing a six-year jail sentence for robbery. He phoned Scotland Yard, saying he ran because he had no credible alibi for the time in question, but repeated several times that he had nothing to do with it. He was eventually caught in Blackpool on October 11, and on October 14 Valerie Storie picked him out of an Identity Parade, after each of the men in the parade had repeated the phrase used by the murderer, "Be quiet, will you? I'm thinking."

Hanratty was charged with the murder of Gregsten, and his trial started at Bedfordshire Assizes on 22 January 1962. The trial was originally planned for the Old Bailey and it is not known why it was resited to Bedfordshire, where there was, understandably, strong feeling against the defendant. Among the prosecution team at the trial was Geoffrey Lane, who was subsequently appointed Lord Chief Justice.

[edit] The Trial

Hanratty's initial defence was that he was in Liverpool on the day of the murder, but then, halfway through the trial, changed part of his story, claiming in fact that he was in Rhyl in North Wales. This was odd, as his defence appeared initially to be good. At that time there was no conclusive forensic evidence to connect Hanratty with the car or the murder scene. Although Hanratty's blood group was the same as the murderer's, it was a common blood type shared by half the population, and there was no evidence that Hanratty had ever been in the Maidenhead area. Although he was a professional thief, he had no convictions for violence, and apparently had never had a gun. Moreover, the murderer drove badly, whereas Hanratty was an experienced car thief. Hanratty did not know either of the two victims, and had no logical motive to commit the murder.

[edit] First Defence – The Liverpool Alibi

Hanratty claimed that he was staying with friends in Liverpool at the time of the murder, but never identified the people involved. The best evidence was that he was there at least on the afternoon of the 22nd. Hanratty claimed that his suitcase had been handed in to Lime Street Station to a 'man with a withered or turned hand'. At the trial the prosecution called Peter Stringer, who had an artificial arm, and not unnaturally denied ever having seen the suitcase or Hanratty. However, there was another person called William Usher, who did have two fingers missing from one hand, which looked 'turned'. He did admit to remembering Hanratty and the suitcase, and remembered the name of the man as 'Ratty'; he was located by private detectives working for the defence, but was never called as a witness.

Hanratty said he had called into a sweet shop in Scotland Road and asked directions to 'Carleton' or 'Tarleton' Road. The Police tracked down a Mrs Dinwoodie, who did indeed run a sweetshop in Scotland Road, who recalled a man like Hanratty asking for directions. However, she was unsure whether it was Monday 21st or Tuesday 22nd. On the other hand, there was also plenty of evidence that Hanratty had been in London all day on Monday 21st. In the morning he had definitely collected a suit from a dry cleaners' in Swiss Cottage; he had definitely been to his friend Charles France's house on the Monday afternoon, and at the Vienna Hotel in the evening. This defence therefore claimed that he could not have travelled to Liverpool to the sweetshop incident and then back in time to commit the murder at 9 p.m. on Tuesday. However, there was still doubt where Hanratty spent the evening of Tuesday 22nd. Just before the Defence opened its case, Hanratty changed part of his alibi.

[edit] Second Defence – The Rhyl Alibi

Hanratty stated to his defence barrister that he had invented part of the Liverpool story as he was unsure he could prove where he was. He then stated that he had in fact been in the Welsh coastal town of Rhyl. Within a few days, the defence had checked and assembled a new alibi for Hanratty. According to this, Hanratty had gone to Rhyl to sell a stolen watch to a 'fence'. He had arrived there late in the evening of Tuesday 22nd and had stayed in a boarding house near the railway station, in the attic room, which had a green bath. Private detectives tracked down a Mrs Grace Jones, a landlady with a guest house whose layout exactly matched the description given by Hanratty, including the green bath in the attic. She remembered a man resembling Hanratty, and was sure it was during the week of 19-26th August.

Following the prosecution's dropping of the book's leaves all over the court, her hotel registers and accounts were in chaos, and little information could be extracted from them; and worse, the prosecution produced a string of witnesses who showed that all the rooms were fully occupied at the time. The prosecution accused Mrs Jones of lying simply to gain publicity for her guest house, leaving her almost in tears. However, counsel for the defence managed to salvage something, showing in fact the attic was empty on the night of 22nd and a bedroom exactly described by Hanratty was free on 23rd, showing that he could have stayed there as claimed. Eventually, the jury retired, and after six hours returned to ask the judge for the definition of 'reasonable doubt'. They returned to the court and entered a unanimous verdict of guilty, after nine hours. Hanratty's appeal was dismissed on March 9, and despite a petition signed by more than 90,000 people, Hanratty was hanged at Bedford on 4 April 1962, still protesting his innocence.

[edit] Evidential anomalies

[edit] Prosecution Evidence

  • In the second line up, Valerie Storie picked Hanratty (though she admitted she only ever saw the face of the man for a second or two in the lights of a car headlamp while he raped her).
  • John Silkett picked out Hanratty as the driver of the Morris Minor as it sped down Eastern Avenue (his companion, Edward Blackall, who had a closer view of the man, did not).
  • James Trower identified Hanratty as driving the Morris as it turned into Redbridge Lane (Trower's companion was adamant that Trower couldn't have seen him from where they were standing).
  • Another prosecution witness was Roy Langdale, who was serving time in prison, and claimed that Hanratty confessed to him. (Two others that Hanratty exercised with said that Hanratty consistently denied any involvement.)
  • Charlie France, a friend of Hanratty's, testified that Hanratty had said to him once that 'the back seat of a bus was a good place to hide something'.

[edit] Defence Evidence

  • No witnesses were able to place Hanratty in the vicinity of Dorney Reach (Valerie Storie excepted)
  • Elsie Cobb said that around 14:30 on 21 August she saw a man passing her house who she described as aged 27 to 30, 5 foot 6 with dark hair brushed back and a thin nose. Her neighbour Frederick Newell added that the man had a sallow complexion.
  • The gunman said "I've been in institutions since I was eight", Hanratty would not use words like "institutions".
  • Mary Lanz proprietor of the Old Station Inn, Taplow where Gregsten and Storie had last been before the cornfield was later able to identify Alphon as having also been there.
  • Even if the Rhyl alibi is disregarded, Hanratty's meeting with Olive Dinwoodie would make his presence in Dorney Reach by 9 p.m. extremely implausible.
  • On Thursday 24 August at 20:40 Hanratty sent a telegram from Lime Street, Liverpool in which he purported to be in London
  • In the first line up, Valerie Storie picked out with total certainty an innocent sailor instead of the police suspect Alphon
  • In the second line up, Hanratty stood out as his hair was bright orange and the police were so concerned about this they considered acquiring skullcaps
  • Although the cartridge cases were found in the Hotel Vienna, no one ever adequately explained how they came to be there the day before the murder.
  • Hanratty disposed of his suit jacket 6 weeks after the crime, Alphon disposed of his raincoat straightaway.
  • Unlike the gunman's description of himself, Hanratty had never lived in a house with a cellar (let alone been locked in one and given only bread and water), was not coming up for PD, had not served five years for housebreaking and had already been in prison on the Isle of Wight.
  • Valerie Storie had said that Jim was obviously not the gunman's real name despite what the gunman claimed.
  • Juliana Galves said she saw Alphon with a pair of black gloves on his suitcase during his stay in the Vienna.
  • Peter Alphon wrote to the Daily Express in 1962 saying he believed Hanratty was innocent and he supported a reprieve.
  • Peter Alphon wrote to the Home Secretary in 1962 saying "I killed Gregsten".
  • In her original statement, Valerie Storie states the man who abducted her was in his 30s, whereas in her second statement she changed this to 'mid 20s'. Hanratty was 25 but Alphon was 31.

[edit] Evidence emerging after Hanratty's execution

A group of people called the 'A6 Defence Committee' was set up to assist Hanratty in his defence. It was instrumental in uncovering new evidence, albeit too late. Twelve years after the execution, the Committee discovered the original statement made by Valerie Storie, which was neither referred to nor available at the trial or the appeal. By 1968, the A6 Committee had found six substantial witnesses to show Hanratty had in fact been to Rhyl. They had also found a fairground worker called Terry Evans who admitted to letting Hanratty stay at his house early in 1961, and to fencing a stolen watch for him. Another man, Trevor Dutton, had just made a payment into his bank account, and consequently his bank book was stamped with the correct date, 23 August, when minutes later he was approached by a man with a cockney accent in a smart suit, trying to sell a gold watch.

The problem here for the conviction was that there were now six witnesses who could positively say they had seen or spoken to Hanratty on the 23rd, and what is more, the day in question was the only day that all six were in Rhyl at the same time.

[edit] Who killed Gregsten?

During 1962, the case caught the interest of a businessman called Jean Justice, whose hobby was the Law. Justice tracked down Peter Alphon in February 1962, and began a long friendship with him for the purposes of establishing the truth. Justice attended the trial every day, being driven there by his chauffeur, and Alphon accompanied him from time to time.

Very slowly, over the months, Alphon began to confess to Justice, including drawing diagrams of the murder scene and demonstrating precise knowledge of details of the events on Deadman's Hill. Justice took the precaution of making thorough notes, and recording all telephone conversations with Alphon. When Alphon found out, he flew into a rage. As it got closer to Hanratty's execution date, Alphon's behaviour became more and more bizarre. He started to bombard his own solicitor with threatening phone calls and letters, and Charles France was also bombarded with phone calls, saying on several occasions, "If Hanratty dies, you die."

France committed suicide about two weeks before the execution, pouring spite and venom in a suicide letter to Hanratty, but at no point actually accusing him of committing the murder. France left behind several letters for his family, the contents of which have never been made public.

[edit] Alphon's Account

Eventually, Alphon's continued confessions formed a picture. According to him, a man had paid him a sum of £5,000 to end the affair between Gregsten and Storie. Another man obtained a gun for Alphon, and Alphon had set off and hijacked the pair. According to Alphon, he gave Gregsten two chances to get away but "each time the bloody man kept coming back". He claimed the gun went off by accident. There was a plan for this eventuality: Alphon says he travelled to Southend and gave the gun to France, who was to dispose of it. France had a grudge against Hanratty, who had had an affair with France's daughter, so he planted the gun under the bus seat and the two cartridges in the hotel.

On 22 August 1962 Alphon visited the Hanratty family and offered to compensate them for their son's death. They threw him out of their house and in a fracas the following day, Alphon assaulted Mary Hanratty. A BBC Panorama programme in 1966 included extracts from the Jean Justice tapes. In May 1967 there was a bizarre press conference, in which Alphon confessed to the world media and related the full story of the gun, the £5,000 and France's involvement. Alphon stuck with his confession and continued to repeat it up to about 1971. Sceptics noted that he had been paid considerable sums of money by Justice and had recanted after he had secured his payments[citation needed]. However Bob Woffinden writes (in Chapter 20 at page 332 in the paperback) that there was only one occasion when Justice and Jeremy Fox supported Alphon financially (when Fox paid a hotel bill for him). Alphon was also to decline money and publicity when offered the opportunity to appear on national TV being interviewed by David Frost on 16 November 1967.

Eventually, the A6 Committee made a list of facts that, in their view, pointed towards Alphon being the killer:

  • Alphon resembles the identikit pictures more than Hanratty did.
  • When stressed, Alphon lapses into cockney.
  • He never produced a convincing alibi to the police.
  • He provides a more credible motive than Hanratty can.
  • He is a poor driver.
  • Paul Foot obtained a copy of his bank account, showing that Alphon did indeed receive payments in cash totalling £7,569 between October 1961 and June 1962. Alphon is unable to account for £5,000 of these payments.

The A6 Committee have also pointed out that the police have consistently refused to investigate Alphon's confessions and credibility in the light of the new evidence.

[edit] Official Inquiries

Three Home Office inquiries have been set up. Detective Superintendent Douglas Nimmo reported on 22 March 1967, Lewis Hawser QC reported on 10 April 1975 and Detective Chief Superintendent Roger Matthews reported on 29 May 1996. The Home Secretary Roy Jenkins received the first two and Michael Howard received the third. On 19 March 1997, the Home Office referred the case to the new Criminal Cases Review Commission where Baden Skitt chaired the investigation.

[edit] DNA evidence and appeal in 2002

In 1991 Bedfordshire Police allowed Bob Woffinden access to their previously undisclosed files on the case. The CCRC report had also revealed the mileage on the Morris Minor which invalidated Skillet's sighting in Brentwood and Trower's in Redbridge Lane. Bob Woffinden writes that there is no evidence that they even saw the same Morris Minor. These anomalies were considered sufficiently significant to justify an appeal against the conviction on behalf of Hanratty's family.

The surviving exhibits from the trial were lost until 1991, when they were found in envelopes in a laboratory drawer. DNA was donated by Hanratty's relatives, which they expected to exonerate him when compared with material on surviving evidence. Results from testing in June 1999 were said to be equivocal.

Hanratty's body was exhumed in 2001 in order to extract DNA. [6] This was compared with mucus preserved in the handkerchief within which the murder weapon had been found wrapped. It was also compared with semen preserved in the underwear worn by Storie when she was raped. No forensic evidence from the crime had previously been linked to Hanratty, yet DNA samples from both sources matched Hanratty's DNA. At the subsequent appeal hearing Michael Mansfield QC, the barrister acting for the Hanratty family, admitted that if contamination can be excluded then the DNA evidence demonstrated that Hanratty committed the murder and rape. He went on to claim that the evidence may have been contaminated because of lax handling procedures. Amongst the surviving evidence a vial had been broken which could account for contamination. However, neither sample yielded DNA from any second male source, as would presumably have been expected if another male had committed the crimes and the samples had subsequently been contaminated.

The argument for contamination was dismissed as "fanciful" by the judges, who concluded that the "DNA evidence, standing alone, is certain proof of guilt". [7]

Hanratty's family and their supporters have continued to contest this conclusion.

[edit] See also

[edit] Sources and references

  1. ^ GRO Register of Births: DEC 1936 2a 1038 BROMLEY, mmn = Wilson
  2. ^ GRO Register of Deaths: JUN 1962 4a 18 BEDFORD, aged 25
  3. ^ The last hangings, of Peter Anthony Allen and Gwynne Owen Evans, occurred two years later on the August 13 1964.
  4. ^ BBC ON THIS DAY | 22 | 1962: 'A6 murder' trial begins
  5. ^ DNA proves Hanratty guilt 'beyond doubt' - Telegraph
  6. ^ The Daily Telegraph
  7. ^ Daily Telegraph report

[edit] External links

Various websites have taken this cause on: