Talk:Islam/Comments

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

as I mentioned on its talk page, the Islam article is extremely well-cited, well-written, as NPOV as one can get in a religion article, broad, etc...

I honestly couldn't find many weaknesses. It is difficult to put the essence of a religion in less than 100 kilobytes and I think the collaborating editors did an extraordinary job organizing and making this into a Good Article. I know little about Islam; I learned a lot from this article and it left me desiring to know more.

That having been said, I took this on as my first ever review so the whole criteria is new to me, but I hope others agree that this is worthy to be called a good article. --Valley2city^₪‽ 08:11, 3 May 2007 (UTC)