Category talk:Islands in the British Isles

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Do we really need to refer to the British Isles when many of us in Ireland find the expression tiresome? Notjim 19:41, 21 Jan 2005 (UTC)

Unfortunately it's the collective term not just for the twin pair of Great Britain and Ireland, but also the assorted other islands (e.g. Isle of Man). You will note that the Irish islands are safely tucked away in their own wee category. This parent category is not particularly controversial, much as you may dislike the term "British Isles".

Just make sure you use the phrase "Britain and Ireland" or "the UK and Ireland" to refer to the two STATES collectively (the British Isles is a grossly politically jarring term to use in that context).

zoney ♣ talk 23:10, 21 Jan 2005 (UTC)

I lived for ages in Britain and came to the conclusion that the habit of thinking of Britain and Ireland as a useful category "the British Isles" usually carried with it some patronizing cultural assumption. Why a category of British Isles, lets go for broke and change the category to "Islands of the North Atlantic" or even "Atlandtic Islands", I am happy to do the work and I think it would be as useful, if not more useful than the current category. Notjim 11:14, 22 Jan 2005 (UTC)

Islands of the North Atlantic, although coined by the govts. is a particularly meaningless term - it in theory encompasses many other islands on both sides of the Atlantic.

Atlantic Islands is even worse, that includes the Azores, Canaries, etc.

Britain and Ireland refers to JUST those two islands. Now one could indeed have "Islands around Britain and Ireland", but I think that is unnecessary. While I dislike the term "British Isles" (being Irish myself) - I think it's reasonably acceptable for a geographical definition, just as much as it is acceptable to categorise geographical features in Northern Ireland as "Irish" (i.e. Mountains of Ireland encompasses the whole island).

zoney ♣ talk 16:14, 22 Jan 2005 (UTC)

I wasn't suggesting Islands of the North Atlantic as a synonym for British Isles, I was suggesting it as an alternate and more useful category. My claim is that there is no reason to have a British Isles category, it is an old habit based on the idea that the islands are somehow British and therefore constitute a useful, distinct category. Why have a category that includes the Hebrides and excludes the Faroes? The point, somehow, is not just that British Isles is a bad name for these islands, but that the habit of thinking of these islands as being a distinct group is old-fashioned and laden with culture assumptions.Notjim 21:08, 23 Jan 2005 (UTC)