Ian Thorpe false start controversy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

In late March 2004 at the Australian Championships in Sydney, Ian Thorpe lined up in the heats of the 400 m freestyle, but overbalanced whilst on the blocks and fell into the water, resulting in his disqualification.[1] An attempted appeal, asserting that a noise had caused him to make his mistake, was dismissed, ending his chance to defend the 400 m Olympic title. This prompted widespread debate, with former swimmer Shane Gould asserting that the selection policy should be relaxed to maximise Australia's chances by selecting Thorpe, whilst Talbot, head coach Leigh Nugent and Kieren Perkins defended the selection policy. Public debate was also widespread, with Prime Minister of Australia John Howard describing the situation as a "tragedy".[2][3] Despite the intense media spotlight, Thorpe managed to win the 100 m and 200 m freestyle events in times of 48.83s and 1 min 45.07s respectively to ensure his selection for Athens. Craig Stevens, who had claimed the second qualifying position in the 400 m event, subsequently faced immense public pressure to relinquish his position to Thorpe, with The Australian's front-page headline reading "Only one man can come to the rescue". Although Thorpe said that Stevens should not be pressured into stepping aside, he was also criticised by columnists who felt that he was inherently pressuring Stevens, for not unequivocally ruling himself out. Stevens later relinquished the position, in an interview with the Seven Network who paid him A$130,000 for the rights to broadcast his announcement.[1] This generated ethical debate as to whether Stevens had made a decision in the national interest or sold Thorpe a gold medal, with The Sydney Morning Herald's headline reading "It's your race, Ian, at $325 a metre".[4][5][6] Thorpe accepted the position and was further attacked by Perkins, who described the affair as "grubby" and "a very, very sad tale for Australian sport", saying the pressure put upon Stevens was "disgusting".[7][8]

[edit] References

  1. ^ a b "Ian Thorpe - Career at a glance", Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2006-11-21. Retrieved on 2006-11-22. 
  2. ^ Magnay, Jacquelin. "I'm over it already, says a gracious Thorpe", The Sydney Morning Herald, 2004-03-24. Retrieved on 2006-11-14. 
  3. ^ Bannerman, Mark. "Thorpe's tumble divides nation", Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2004-03-29. Retrieved on 2006-11-14. 
  4. ^ "Ian Thorpe: On course to sink Athens opposition", ABC, 2004. Retrieved on 2006-11-14. 
  5. ^ Bannerman, Mark. "Stevens announcement raises financial questions for world sport" (The 7.30 report, transcript), Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2004-04-29. Retrieved on 2006-11-14. 
  6. ^ Cowley, Michael. "It's your race, Ian, at $325 a metre", The Sydney Morning Herald, 2004-04-27. Retrieved on 2006-11-14. 
  7. ^ Hunter (2004), pp. 354-359.
  8. ^ Solly, Ross. "O'Neill, Perkins urge Stevens to stand firm", Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2004-03-29. Retrieved on 2006-11-14.