Humour in Freud

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is orphaned as few or no other articles link to it. Please help introduce links in articles on related topics. (May 2008)

Freud established that humor might be related with unconscious content². In “Jokes and Their Relation to The Unconscious" as well as in “Humor” Freud referred to contentious jokes ⁷. He distinguishes humor in three particular forms: joke, comic and mimetic. ³

Contents 1 Freud's theory of humor 2 The different types of humor 3 Criticism 4 References

[edit] Freud's theory of humor

In his view, jokes happen when the conscious allows forbidden thoughts which society suppresses.The superego allows the ego to generate humor². A benevolent superego allows a light and comforting type of humor while a harsh superego creates a biting and sarcastic type of humor³. A very harsh superego suppresses humor all together^[1]. Freud’s humor theory was based on the dynamic between id, ego and superego⁷. The commanding superego will impede the ego to continue its pleasure-seeking from the id, or to momentarily adapt itself to the demands of reality⁷. Moreover Freud (1960)³ also contributes to the development of the relief theory of laughter in which he proposed that emotional energy is released by humor sense. Later Freud re-turned his attention to humor noting that everyone is not capable of formulating humor^3,8.

[edit] The different types of humor

Freud describes jokes as letting in forbidden thoughts and feelings which society suppresses into the conscious mind^2,3. Thus, there is an interaction between the unconscious and the conscious thoughts. For example Valerie Sinason (1994) mentions an eight years old patient who made a l joke of her profession when he accused her of being a "PISS-CO-ANAL-CYST", or a "PSYCHO-THE-RAPIST" ⁹.

Mimetic on the other hand is a process involving two different representations of the body in our mind^2,3,7. For example the phrase “He has his heart in the right place” The heart has two representations, one which is anatomical, while the other is a metaphorical way of being at peace with one self^[2].

The 'comic is “to apply to one and the same act of ideation two different ideational methods” (Freud, 1905, 300; as cited in ⁷. William Shakespeare’s Falstaff would be Freud's best example of the "comic", generating laughter by utilizing once repressed inhibition ⁴.An upset American says at Sunday School: "(Roosevelt) is my Shepherd; I am in want. He makes me to lie down on park benches; he leads me in the paths of destruction for His party's sake"⁶.

[edit] Criticism

Modern critics debate that Freud's division is artificial and not very clear^1,8. According to Altman (2006)¹ these three different types of humor are divided more in a semantically way than in a functional one. Hence, all three types of humor are a result of the dynamic of the conscious and unconscious^1,8. For example hate and anger can be hidden by a false sense of love and compassion which could be the opposite of what is meant and thus formulating a joke^3,1,7

[edit] References

¹Altman, N. (2006). And now for something completely different: humor in psychoanalysis. Psychoanalytic Dialogues, 16(5),573-577.

²Freud, S. (1928). Humor. International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 9, 1-6.

³Freud, S. (1960). Jokes and their relation to the unconscious. (J. Strachey, Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. (Original work published 1905).

⁴Kincaid, J. R. (2001). Falstaff as an example for Freud’s “comic”. http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/kincaid2, retrieved from the web on the 12th May 2008.

⁵Marshall, R. (2004). Getting even on the jest propelled couch: humor and play in psychoanalysis. Modern psychoanalysis. 1(29),63-76.

⁶Martin J. (2006) Studies in American humor, University of Southern California, http://www.compedit.com/introduction.htm retrieve from the web 17th may 2008.

⁷Matte, G. (2001). A psychoanalytical perspective of humor. Humor, 14(3),223-241.

⁸Newirth, J. (2006). Jokes and their relation to the unconscious: humor as a fundamental emotional experience. Psychoanalytic dialogues, 16(5),557-571.

⁹Smuts, A. (2006). The internet encyclopedia of philosophy, Humor. http://www.iep.utm.edu/h/humor.htm#H3, retrieved from the web on the 12th of April 2008.

This article is uncategorized. Please categorize this article to list it with similar articles. (May 2008)