Homosexuality in ancient Rome

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Sources for Ancient Roman homosexual practice, and attitudes and acceptance of it are abundantly available. There are literary works, poems, graffiti and comments on the sexual predelictions of single emperors. Graphic representations are, on the other hand, rarer in ancient Rome than in classical Greece. Attitudes towards homosexuality changed over the time and from context to context, ranging from strong condemnation to quite open acceptance. Indeed, it was also purported to be one of the cultural facts of certain provinces.

In discussing such attitudes, it is fundamental to recall that the term "homosexuality" is entirely problematic for the ancient world since there is no single word in either Latin or ancient Greek with the same meaning as the modern concept of homosexuality. Although it again and again becomes apparent that bisexuality was more the norm, even the ancient authors agree that there were ancient Roman men who had sexual relations exclusively with men.

Contents 1 History 1.1 Early Republic 1.2 Mid and late Republic 1.3 Empire 2 Discussion 2.1 Roles and preferences 2.2 Subculture 2.3 Female homosexuality 2.4 Moral opinions 3 Notes 4 Literature 5 See also 6 External links

[edit] History

[edit] Early Republic

In the early Roman Republic, pederasty was considered a degenerate Greek practice and as such was generally forbidden or not done.

[edit] Mid and late Republic

As Greek attitudes gradually became accepted in Rome during the late Republic and early Empire, however, a new form of same-sex relations emerged that was quite different from homosexuality in ancient Greece, but owed much to it. As men, particularly the pater familias, wielded complete authority in Roman society, the Roman experience of same-sex relations is often characterized by master/slave-style interactions. Slaves still were considered legitimate sexual partners, often if not always regardless of their wishes. In short, an adult Roman citizen male could acceptably penetrate (whether a male or a female) but not be penetrated - catamite was commonly used as a slander.

[edit] Empire

Though perhaps not the originator of the practice, the emperor Nero appears to have been the first Roman emperor to marry a male. According to Edward Gibbon, writing in 1776, of the first twelve emperors only Claudius was exclusively involved with women. All others took either boys or men as lovers.^[1] The fact that Claudius had no male lovers actually drew criticism from Suetonius.

Pederasty largely lost its status as a ritual part of education — a process already begun by the increasingly sophisticated and cosmopolitan Greeks — and was instead seen as an activity primarily driven by one's sexual desires and competing with desire for women. The social acceptance of pederastic relations waxed and waned during the centuries. Conservative thinkers condemned it — along with other forms of indulgence. Tacitus attacks the Greek customs of "gymnasia et otia et turpes amores" (palaestrae, idleness, and shameful loves). ^[2]

Other writers spent no effort censuring pederasty per se, but praised or blamed its various aspects. Martial appears to have favored it, going as far as to essentialize not the sexual use of the catamite but his nature as a boy: upon being discovered by his wife "inside a boy" and offered the "same thing" by her, he retorts with a list of mythological personages who, despite being married, took young male lovers, and concludes by rejecting her offer since "a woman merely has two vaginas." ^[3] Among the Romans, pederasty reached its zenith during the time of hellenophile emperor Hadrian. A man whose passion for boys paralleled that of his predecessor, Trajan, he fell in love with Antinous, a young teenage Greek, and had his eromenos deified upon the latter's premature death. Commodus had a number of male lovers. Elagabalus also had numerous male lovers and even married one of these in a public ceremony. Philip the Arabian was also known for his fondness for young men.

[edit] Discussion

[edit] Roles and preferences

While it was the norm in Greece and Rome that the younger partner was passive and the older active, there is (especially from the Roman period) evidence that older men preferred the passive role. Martial describes, for example, the case of an older man who played the passive role and let a younger slave occupy the active role.^[4] Often it was also assumed that only the active participant gained pleasure from sexual intercourse. In general, the passive role was equated with the role of a woman and therefore felt to be rather low. Suetonius reported that the Emperor Nero, in taking the passive sexual role with the freedmen Doryphorus, imitated the screams and whimpering of a young woman.^[5] Men taking the passive role were often liable to be accused to take too much care of their appearance to attract and please potential active partners. Such men were usually shown in a negative light, having the word kinaidos / cinaedus applied to them (which could also be applied to eunuchs).

There are also other examples. Again Suetonius reported that Emperor Galba felt drawn to strong and experienced men.^[6] More than once it is reported that soldiers were sexually assaulted by their higher officers.^[7]

In addition to repeatedly described anal intercourse, there is also plenty of evidence that oral sex was normal. Here graffiti from Pompeii is unambiguous: "Secundus is a cocksucker of rare ability."^[8] In contrast to ancient Greece, a large penis was a major element in attractiveness. In Petronius is a description of how a man with such a large penis in a public bathroom looked up, excited.^[9] Several emperors are reported in a negative light for surrounding themselves with men with large sexual organs. ^[10]

[edit] Subculture

There are at least some signs that something approaching a homosexual subculture was already starting to develop in ancient Rome, although it certainly does not compare with modern subcultures. In Rome around 200 BC there was already a road where male prostitutes preferred staying^[11], specialising in either the passive or active role. Other men searched for sailors in the vicinity of districts close to the Tiber.^[12] Public baths are also referred to as a place to find sexual partners. Juvenal states that such men scratched their heads with a finger to identify themselves.

[edit] Female homosexuality

By the first century AD, there is a larger scope of sources on the possibility of female homosexuality. Ovid denied the possibility that such a thing ever existed.^[13] Later comments, however, are extremely hostile, and even go as far as the killing of a woman by her husband.^[14] Martial himself, who shows himself to be amused by all other kinds of 'deviation', has a very negative opinion of lesbian love.^[15] In Egypt, however, some love spells in Greek have been found, which were clearly written by a woman the purpose of winning the heart of another woman, and so female homosexuality clearly occurred elsewhere in the Empire outside of Rome itself, and was not always seen in such a negative light.^{[citation needed]}

[edit] Moral opinions

Above all, pederasty was condemned in the Republican era and dismissed as a sign of an effeminate Greek lifestyle. In the mid Republic homosexual acts were widely accepted, if the active partner was a Roman, and the passive partner a slave or non-Roman. Deviations from this pattern were morally condemned, but apparently had few legal consequences. Martial and Plautus describe a wide range of homosexual behaviors, in part to poke fun at them like other minor standard deviations, but without too much real moralizing. On the other hand, there is also from the year 108 an indictment against C. Vibius Maximus, a Roman officer in Egypt who had a sexual relationship with a young nobleman.

Juvenal condemned many forms of male homosexuality, and especially laments Roman men of high birth who show a moral front but secretly took the passive role. He found men who openly played the passive role pitiful but at least honest, and praised true love found by a man for a boy.^[16] Public speeches usually condemned all forms of homosexuality. When Julius Caesar conqueror held office in Macedon, he had a relationship with the local Nicomedes and played the passive role but, though this damaged his reputation, it apparently had no legal consequences. ^[17] The emperor Hadrian had a relationship with the younger Antinous, although this was also criticized.

With the arrival of Christianity, but perhaps also a little earlier, all kinds of same-sex love became increasingly taboo. In 390, the first law banning same-sex love was enacted, making it punishable by death.^[18]

The circumstances surrounding the massacre of Thessaloniki at the end of the 4th century post offers a clue that even in the Christian era homosexuality itself was still accepted in large parts of the population, while officially prosecuted. A popular wagon driver was accused of having sexually harassed an army-commander or servant of the emperor. The wagon driver was arrested, but pointed out there was unrest, as the people of the town were calling for his release. The wagon driver also enjoyed great popularity despite his homosexuality.^{[citation needed]}

[edit] Notes

[edit] Literature

• Thomas K. Hubbard: Homosexuality in Greece and Rome, a Sourcebook of Basic Documents. Los Angeles, London 2003. ISBN 0-520-23430-8
• Craig Williams: Roman Homosexuality, Ideologies of Masculinity in Classical Antiquity. in: Oxford University Press (Editor): Ideologies of Desire. Oxford 1999
• The Myth of Homosexuality and the Fall of the Roman Empire
• William Percy: The Age of Marriage in Ancient Rome, Lewiston, New York: The Edwin Mellen Press, 2003 (together with Arnold Lelis and Beert Verstraete)

[edit] See also

• Exoletus

[edit] External links

• World history of homosexual and pederastic relationships

v • d • e LGBT history Antiquity Homosexuality in ancient Greece • Homosexuality in ancient Rome • Homosexuality in ancient Egypt • Khnumhotep & Niankhkhnum • Achilles and Patroclus Early 20th century History of gays during the Holocaust Modern times Stonewall riots • Singapore gay history • History of homosexuality in Singapore (2000s) Other Lesbian American history • Timeline of LGBT history • Timeline of same-sex marriage • History of human sexuality • History of Christianity and homosexuality • History of lesbianism History of same-sex unions

v • d • e Homosexuality around the world Asia Singapore · Japan · China · India · Philippines Europe Ancient Greece · Ancient Rome Oceania LGBT New Zealand Africa Homosexuality in ancient Egypt · LGBT rights in Africa Other LGBT social movements · Bisexuality in the Arab world · Sexual Minorities in Japan