User talk:Henrywilliams58

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Balti wine

I have to admit that your editing pattern is troubling and seem indicative of a Conflict of interest-perhaps financial in the Balti wine article. Your insistence on wanting to turn the article into an advertisement for various companies is not compatible with Wikipedia's guidelines WP:CORP, WP:SPAM and WP:NOT. I have no problem with mention of competitors but in order to comply with Wikipedia guidelines there needs to be Reliable independent 3rd party sources that comment on the nature of the competition to Balti. The company's own website is not an independent 3rd party. On the contrary it is a self reference. There also needs to be more encyclopedic relevance then just Company A is a competitor of Company B. That is just spam advertisement. Rather you need to show "How has the competition affected the history of the company?" (or more interesting-How has it affected the wine world?). Again, there is room for compromise but we must act according to Wikipedia guidelines and if you do have a financial interest in the Balti wine article or in one of its competitor, I respect ask you to review the WP:COI guidelines and refrain from editing the article. Your input on the talk page on how to improve the article will be welcomed. Agne^Cheese/^Wine 19:20, 31 July 2007 (UTC)