Talk:Hayashi track

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

WikiProject Physics This article is within the scope of WikiProject Physics, which collaborates on articles related to physics.
Start This article has been rated as start-Class on the assessment scale.
Mid This article is on a subject of mid importance within physics.

Help with this template This article has been rated but has no comments. If appropriate, please review the article and leave comments here to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article and what work it will need.

[edit] slogging through this

Could this article just start out:

The Hayashi track refers to the path on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram taken by an interstellar cloud which is evolving into a star. The gas contracts and heats by gravitational collapse into a dense core and glows as a black body without any nuclear reactions. At around 4000 K hydrostatic equilibrium is reached and the temperature remains constant. Heat lost by black body radiation is replenished by gravity as collapse continues at a slower pace—this appears as an upwards vertical line on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. The Hayashi track ends and the ... track begins when nuclear fusion is ignited by the rising pressure.

As a layman and lazyman, I can't be sure of this or verify it, but it would seem to summarize how I interpret the article. Astronomers have a habit of stating ideas very precisely without connecting to related ideas and fusion doesn't even merit a mention here for some reason... Potatoswatter 05:09, 3 April 2007 (UTC)

Well, what's wrong with your text is:
  • `protostar' is the accepted term for `an interstellar cloud which is evolving into a star' -- so it would be confusing not to use it.
  • It's true that the heating is by conversion of gravitational into internal energy, and it's true that an optically thick object appears as a black body -- but neither of these is at all a particular feature of the Hayashi track. They're also true of clouds before they reach the track and of pre-main-sequence stars after they leave it.
  • Clouds are in approximate hydrostatic eqm before they reach the Hayashi track.
  • The track of a particular protostar is a downwards vertical line on the H-R diagram.
  • The track doesn't end when fusion is ignited (except for very low-mass stars) but, as the article says, when the core becomes hot enough that radiative energy transport is important. Then you get the Henyey track which takes you to fusion and the main sequence. Fusion isn't mentioned because it isn't relevant at either end of the track. It would help if it were mentioned explicitly in the Henyey track article...

Hope this makes things clearer. Mhardcastle 07:26, 3 April 2007 (UTC)

Haha... so that's the academic answer. Let me try again then.
The Hayashi track refers to a linear path on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram taken by a protostar, an interstellar cloud of gas evolving into a star. The gas contracts and heats by gravitational collapse into a dense core and glows as a black body without any nuclear reactions. Hydrostatic forces give the cloud its shape and size, as gas pressure due to heat balances gravity. The Hayashi track begins when the temperature reaches approximately 4000 K and remains constant. Across a wide range of stellar masses, this is the final equilibrium temperature when collapse due to gravity is complete. However, the protostar continues to shrink due to heat lost to space through black body radiation. This causes decreasing surface area and decreasing brightness. As it remains at hydrostatic equilibrium, the temperature remains a constant 4000 K. These trends form a downwards vertical line on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. Eventually the protostar becomes small enough that the temperature gradient becomes significant. Pressure at the center is greater, causing correspondingly higher temperature. On the Hayashi track convection or "churning" keeps the protostar near a consistent 4000 K throughout. The Hayashi track ends and the Henyey track begins when the fluid is too dense for convection to maintain constant temperature. On the Henyey track, the temperature rises with very slowly increasing density until fusion begins.
I feel like I understand now :v) ... this needs a few paragraph breaks but let me know if it's alright... Potatoswatter 10:47, 28 April 2007 (UTC)