Template talk:Hasidic dynasties

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents 1 Regions 2 Strashelye 3 Award to the template's creator 4 Chabad

[edit] Regions

There are two pages on the Template. The first group should be Podolia- Ukraine, not Russia. Or Eastern Ukraine. Tolne should be in this group not in the Galcia group. --Jayrav 21:04, 8 July 2007 (UTC)

Two pages??? the first group were in the Russian Empire. Podolia maybe (certainly not Ukraine, which did not yet exist), but chasidim do refer to these dynasties as 'Russian'. Will check Talne. --Redaktor 22:39, 8 July 2007 (UTC)

Moved Talne—thanks for spotting this. --Redaktor 22:52, 8 July 2007 (UTC)

You have to be consistant to call the regions all by the same time frame. They were all founded under the Polish commenwealth, at that time Russia was only the regions further east. Even after the Russian empire, the area was Podolia. It only became "Russia" in the 20th century. Are we using 1780? 1840? or 1950? Pick a date and then we can standardize and add tags. I vote to use Podolia. --Jayrav 00:42, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

Your divisions of Galcia and Hungary will change based on the date. You need to decide on the date used to set the template. --Jayrav 00:44, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

I don't want to get into a major argument over this, but the Russian Empire existed in the 18th century, not just the 20th! Very few, if any, Hasidic dynasties came into existence during the Polsih Commonwealth. 1815 might be a good date to choose (Congress of Vienna). --Redaktor 05:07, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

The region/country list is definitely inconsistent. I don't know enough about the political history, and who controlled what when. But I believe using regional names provides more consistency than countries/empires, since they didn't shift with the same frequency. Everything listed here under Russia should be either in Volhynia or Podolia. --Kotzker 23:04, 19 July 2007 (UTC)

Also, it appears from here that the region was known as Ukraine for quite some time -- and not just as a geographical region, but also as a political entity (at least as far back as the Treaty of Pereyaslav in 1654). --Kotzker 23:25, 19 July 2007 (UTC)

I think that I have already put all the Vohlin locations in the right list (correct me if I am wrong). The rest are Russian Podolia, so I could change the name. The name Ukraine was, AFAIK, not usd by Jews before WW1. I was trying to capture the names used by Jews eg Russian chasidus, Litvish chasidus, Galitzyaner chasidus. --Redaktor 07:24, 20 July 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Strashelye

Strashelye really should be in Lita, no?--Meshulam 18:08, 15 July 2007 (UTC)

You are quite right—thank you for noting this. --Redaktor 22:52, 15 July 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Award to the template's creator

In recognition of the superlative and complex work of User Redaktor (talk · contribs) in creating this magnificent, unique and trailblazing template, I have awarded him {{The da Vinci Barnstar}} as follows [1] [2]:

		The da Vinci Barnstar
		This award is in recognition of all your wonderful technical and editorial work related to topics about Judaism, as your user page testifies. In particular, I was won over by your creation and work on Template:Hasidic dynasties. Mazel Tov and may you be blessed to continue contributing to Wikipedia in this productive fashion for a long time to come. Sincerely, IZAK 08:36, 9 November 2007 (UTC)

Thank you User:Redaktor for all your great work and efforts to enhance the quality, scope and depth of articles relating to Judaism. IZAK 09:39, 12 November 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Chabad

Isn't Chabad a Russian chassidus? The link to the Chabad page even says as such. I won't change it if others object, but I wouldn't call Chabad a Lita based chassidus. Yossiea ^(talk) 19:45, 15 November 2007 (UTC)