Wikipedia:Harmonious Editing Hall of Fame

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is the Hall of Fame for the Harmonious Editing Club. It aims to list articles which have had substantive disagreements solved by mutually respectful dialogue, creating an end-result agreeable to all sides.

• Talk:Pokemon Chronicles - an argument over content is cooled and solved with the injection of fresh ideas and a look at Wikipedia:Neutral point of view
• Talk:Ebonics - some nasty exchanges involving users who seemed to think a description of African American English titled Ebonics was part of a Wikipedia plot to demean black people; discussion ended without resolution, until a calm exchange occurred, almost immediately resulting in a compromise that has suited all sides
• Talk:Singapore - a user fights the good fight against a vandal, seemingly alone, only to find himself restricted by the three revert rule; he has faith in the system, which works, and the vandal is beaten back without breaking the rules
• Talk:Russian humour - page has seen a number of disagreements and discussions, all of which remained amicable and have resulted in an informative article
• Talk:American and British English differences - has seen a wide variety of discussion on a topic that can provoke heartfelt differences, but editing has remained cool and calm, and the article is quite informative
• Talk:Nigger - another very controversial topic that has resulted in much discussion, all of it more or less amicable, and combining to create an interesting article on an important subject
• Talk:Rock and roll - much discussion, all of it productive
• Talk:Boy Scouts of America - gays and lesbians and atheists and non-theistic Unitarians, oh my! Peaceful editing all around, however
• Talk:Holocaust (disambiguation) - a discussion about the relative merits of different uses of the word Holocaust; though at times tense, editing never got into true acrimony