Harvey v. Facey
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Harvey v. Facey, [1893] AC 552 is a Jamaican case decided by the Privy Council in contract law on the difference between an offer and an invitation to treat. The Judicial Committee held that indication of lowest acceptable price does not constitute an offer to sell. Rather, it is considered an offer to treat (i.e., to enter into negotiations).
[edit] Background
The case was regarding the sale of property in Jamaica. The respondent L. M. Facey was carrying on negotiations with the Mayor and Council of Kingston for the sale of the property in question. On the 7th of October 1891, Facey was travelling from Kingston to Porus by train and the appelants caused a telegram to be sent to him saying:
"Will you sell us Bumper Hall Pen? Telegraph lowest cash price-answer paid"
Facey replied on the same day:
"Lowest price for Bumper Hall Pen £900."
The appelants then replied in the following words:
"We agree to buy Bumper Hall Pen for the sum of nine hundred pounds asked by you. Please send us your title deed in order that we may get early possession."
The defendant however refused to sell at that price.
[edit] Opinion of the Court
The Judicial Committee in its judgement pointed out that the plaintiff had asked two questions in the first telegram - as to the defendant's willingness to sell and the lowest price. The defendant only answered the second question and did not reply as to his willingness to sell. Thus he had made no offer. The last telegram of the plaintiffs was an offer to buy but was never accepted.
