Hadith of the pond of Khumm

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Part of a series on the
Succession
to Muhammad


This box: view  talk  edit
Arabic
حدیث غدیر خم
Transliteration
Hadith-i ghadir
Translation
Narration of the pond

Part of a series on
Shi'a Islam

Ahl al-Kisa

Ahl al-Kisa
Muhammad
Ali · Fatimah
Hasan · Husayn

The Four Companions

The Four Companions
Salman al-Farsi
Miqdad ibn Aswad
Abu Dharr al-Ghifari
Ammar ibn Yasir

Beliefs & Practices

Succession of Ali
Imamate of the Family
Mourning of Muharram
Light of Aql · Ismah
Tawassul · Clergy
The Occultation

Views

The Qur'an · Sahaba
Mu'awiya I
Abu Bakr · Umar

History

History of Shia Islam
Ghadir Khumm
First Fitna · Second Fitna
The Battle of Karbala

Holy Days

Eid ul-Fitr · Eid al-Adha
Eid al-Ghadeer
Ashura · Arba'een
Mawlid · Al-Mubahila

Branches

Twelver · Ismaili · Zaidi

v  d  e
This is a sub-article to the Succession to Muhammad
The Investiture of Ali at Ghadir Khumm (MS Arab 161, fol. 162r, AD 1309/8 Ilkhanid manuscript illustration).
The Investiture of Ali at Ghadir Khumm (MS Arab 161, fol. 162r, AD 1309/8 Ilkhanid manuscript illustration).

The Hadith of the pond of Khumm (Arabic: غدير خم‎) refers to the saying (i.e. Hadith) about a historical event crucial to Islamic history. This event took place on March 10, 632 AD at a place called Ghadir Khumm, which is located near the city of al-Juhfah, Saudi Arabia. In Muslim literature, Ghadir Khumm is often referred to as an oasis with a watering hole or pond. Ghadir Khumm is alternately written simply as Khumm, Khur, or Khu'.

Sunni Muslims believe it to be Muhammad's defense of Ali in the face of unjust criticism, while Shi'a Muslims believe it to be an indication of Ali as Muhammad's successor.

Contents

[edit] Background Context

Main Article: Ghadir Khumm

A few months before his death, Muhammad - living at the city of Medina - made his last religious pilgrimage to Mecca in a trip referred to as The Farewell Pilgrimage. There, atop Mount Arafat, he addressed the Muslim masses in what came to be known as The Farewell Sermon. After completion of the Hajj, or religious pilgrimage, Muhammad turned back towards his home in Medina.

On the trip there, he stopped at the pond of Khumm and praised Ali. The exact meaning of the praise is a matter of much dispute; not only do Sunni and Shi'a Muslims disagree as to which staements about the pond are authentic, but they also disagree on the interpretation.

[edit] Sunni and Shi'a Concordance

Part of a series on Islam

Ali
Son-in-law of Muhammad
Fourth Sunni Caliph
First Shi'a Imam




Views:

This box: view  talk  edit

Generally, Sunni and Shi'a Muslims both accept that Muhammad said the following at the pond:

“Whomsoever’s mawla I am, this Ali is also his mawla. O Allah, befriend whosoever befriends him and be the enemy of whosoever is hostile to him.”

However, there is disagreement as to what was said after that. There is also disagreement over the definition of the word "mawla." The Sunni position is that the word translates to "beloved friend," whereas the Shi'a position holds that it translates to "master."

[edit] Shi'a Viewpoint

Shi'a Muslims believe that after the pilgrimage, Muhammad ordered the gathering of Muslims at the pond of Khumm and it was there that Muhammad nominated Ali to be his successor, arguing that it wouldn't have made sense to stop those traveling back to Medina to solely defend Ali from criticism.[1]

[edit] Sunni Viewpoint

The Sunni version of the hadith states that a group of soldiers under the command of Ali were complaining to Muhammad about Ali, and Muhammad defended Ali by praising him. The Sunnis believe that Muhammad's intention behind the praise was not at all to nominate Ali as his successor but rather it was only to defend Ali against the slander being said against him.[2]

Scholars of Sunni Islam reject a number of further additions as being fabricated and unacceptable. They believe that Muhammad praised Ali, but that this cannot be construed as a prophetic nomination due to the fact that Muhammad similarly praised others from amongst the Sahaba.

[edit] Non-Muslim Viewpoint

Non-Muslim historians appear to ignore the incident described in this hadith.

[edit] The Translation of the Word "Mawla"

The word "mawla" is found in a number of verses from the Qur'an. With reference to classical Arabic language itself, both Sunni and Shi'a scholars acknowledge that the word mawla has been used in different ways. The Sunni scholar Ibn al-Athir maintains that the word can be translated as any of the following words: lord, owner, benefactor, liberator, helper, lover, ally, slave, servant, brother-in-law, cousin, or friend.[citation needed] The Shi'a organization Thaqalayn Muslim Association stated in one of its leaflets that it can mean master, friend, slave, or even client.[citation needed]

It is accepted by both Sunni and Shi'a that the proper translation revolves around the context. However, the two groups have very differing views as to what was said at the pond of Khumm and for what purpose those words were said; it is because of this difference that the two groups translate the same word in a different manner.

The word "Mawla" and the entire question of the waliate is discussed in a non-Muslim fashion in a book edited by Monique Bernards and John Nawas called "Patronate and Patronage in Early and Classical Islam" [3]. This book sheds light on the word "maula" but does not resolve the tension between the two interpretations.

By  

[edit] Notes

[edit] See also

[edit] External links

Shia
Sunni