Talk:Guttman scale

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is within the scope of WikiProject Statistics, which collaborates to improve Wikipedia's coverage of statistics. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page.

it seems that the sample guttman scale is of little use, as the first 4 categories are all such that each is implied by the subsequent (i.e. allowing immigrants next door automatically implies you'd allow them in your neighborhood [unless you're in a weird border case where nextdoor isn't in your neighborhood]).

That's the whole point of a Guttman scale, and that is the required structure of the data. Holon 07:15, 29 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] What a horrible mess!!!

This article now begins like this:

A hypothetical, perfect Guttman scale consists of a unidimensional set of items that are ranked in order of difficulty from least extreme to most extreme position. For example, a person scoring a "7" on a ten item Guttman scale, will agree with items 1-7 and disagree with items 8,9,10. An important property of Guttman's model is that a person's entire set of responses to all items can be predicted from their cumulative score because the model is deterministic.

What in hell does that mean? "difficulty" seems to mean there "items" are some sort of tasks that someone is to do. That's just a guess. A guess! Why should the reader have to guess? Then "a person scoring a "7" on a ten item Guttman scale".... So a Guttman scale is something on which someone scores points. Why can't the article just say so instead of leaving us to surmise this. Is this about sports? Tennis, maybe? Or chess? Then: "An important property of Guttman's model is that a person's entire set of responses to all items can be predicted from their cumulative score because the model is deterministic." Really? So someone named "Guttman" has a "model". I still don't know if this is about tennis or weighlifting or academic performance on physics examinations or what.

What a mess. Michael Hardy (talk) 17:15, 22 April 2008 (UTC)