User talk:Gorthaur03

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Please provide greater justification for your envisioning of Eonwe. It's a great image, but it needs justification from the text. It looks far too Christian and not Tolkien-based. As a long-time user of Wikipedia, I didn't find your image necessary or appropiate. That's the point. I have the right to do that. Others have the right to discuss it. Together, we create the encyclopedia.

Until someone can justify this angelic depiction of Eonwe, I don't think it's appropriate for the article. Please refer discussion to the talk page of the article instead of sending it to an unregistered user page that goes to an ip range. Not everyone in the range wants to read angry messages sent to the non-registered user. Also, you didn't post your username correctly when crediting the image to yourself. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 24.206.112.92 (talk) 20:47, 6 April 2008 (UTC)