Talk:Fourth branch of government

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The main definition is vague: "some say" -- who exactly? Can this view be attributed to any specific individual or group? Why the fourth branch of government? No matter what one believes about the US mass media, it is a fact that they are not a de iure part of the government. The traditional term is fourth estate, maybe that is what was meant here? --MarkSweep 15:48, 25 Nov 2004 (UTC)

...the 'fourth estate' is the French term for the same concept. Back in ye olde dayes, the French government was composed of the First, Second, and Third Estates, and some referred to the media of the day as the Fourth Estate (and it was no more a de jure part of government there than it is in the US).

However, the US government does not have Estates, it has Branches, so the local version is the "Fourth branch of government".

[edit] Independent U.S. government agencies

I made a few clarifying edits regarding independent U.S. government agencies. Colloquially referring to an independent agency such as the Federal Communications Commission as part of the "fourth branch" of government is at least arguably "correct" in some sense. We should remember, however, that nearly all "independent" agencies of the U.S. government are technically part of the executive branch. A few are part of the legislative branch (under Congress) -- for example, the Government Accountability Office and the Government Printing Office. There really is no U.S. government agency of which I am aware that could be said to be outside one of the three branches of government. Even the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System is, by law, under the control of the executive branch of government (if push comes to shove), and could be abolished in any case by Congress.

Does anyone have any information about a U.S. government agency that could be said to be "outside" the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government from a technical (legal) standpoint? Yours, Famspear 16:54, 28 September 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Cheney

No one is going to add VP Cheney's fourth-branchness claims? He got a whole article for his hunting accident. —Dmbrown00 02:17, 28 June 2007 (UTC)

I agree, something should be added about this. Lieftastic 04:17, 29 June 2007 (UTC)

indeed, in fact, i was surprised that it wasnt already here. --202.161.21.22 14:33, 7 July 2007 (UTC)