Talk:Four continents
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Random page grade - June 15, 2006
- Four continents
- Well written? - FAILED - there should not be a list in the lead paragraph WP:LEAD.
- Factually accurate? - FAILED - only one source.
- Broad in its coverage? - FAILED - needs to go into more detail about each of the four. This article is little more than a time line.
- NPOV - PASSED
- Is it stable? - YES
- Images - FAILED - "Four Continents" graphic is not explained well at all in the caption - why is Australia pictured?; The placement of the other graphics is bizarre and distracting.
- Davodd 06:00, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
Could do with some mention of Adriaen Collaert and his allegorical 4 continents engravings from late 16th cent. What the hell does Mr Hyde or his collection have to do with anything?? That's just Americocentricity at its most brazen and irrelevant to the actual (poor quality) article. (Peacay 13:30, 30 November 2007 (UTC))
