Talk:Flag semaphore
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] Semaphore code space
- Notice: this discussion's history is available in Talk:Semaphore line
This is how I am determining how many symbols are possible in a flag semaphore scheme. "Across" means the arm is extended across the torso.
The signal for Error is not shown here, as the flags are in motion for that signal, while for all other signals, the flags are held still.
-- Denelson83 05:45, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
The "error" sign is eight "e"s in a row. The article shows the "attention sign" as error. Numerals are not letters of the alphabet, but are spelled out following the "numerals" sign which is the opposite of the letter "Tango" and is used before and after a numeral set, ie, "open numerals T H R E E close numerals". If the numeral sign is not used, the number is spelled out. SM1(SW), USN, (Ret)I55ere (talk) 18:14, 29 March 2008 (UTC)
- But spelling out numbers after the numeral sign completely defeats the purpose of the numeral sign to begin with. You can spell out numbers without using the numeral sign, but if you want to send numbers quicker, the numeral sign changes some of the letters into digits, and then sending the "J" sign means "shift back to letters," just like in the Baudot code. -- Denelson83 04:17, 24 May 2008 (UTC)
-
- Numeral sign is not for speed of transmission, but to facilitate how the number is recorded by the receiver. It may seem redundant, but when a number is sent without the numeral sign, it is recorded as a word, when it is sent with the numeral sign, it is recorded as a digit. Letters are not substituted for numbers. You can easily reference this by obtaining a copy of the SM 3&2, SM 3, QM 3&2, or QM 3 rate Training Manuals provided by the US Navy. "J" is not used in the transmission of numbers as a "prosign", it is used after the attention sign to allow the receiver to tell the sender to move up, down, left, or right to place the sender into a better position for reading. A simple message would go as such... "attention" "J" BT send two "numeral sign" two two "numeral sign" gallon barrels BT K. It would be recorded as BT send two 22 gallon barrels BT K This can easily be verified in Pub 102 (International Code of Signals) and Allied Communications Publication 113 (Visual Signalling Procedures). An SM (Signalman) uses semaphore on a daily basis when communicating with other ships at close range, ie. during underway replenishments. SM1 (SW), USN (RET)I55ere (talk) 14:08, 7 June 2008 (UTC)
The hand positions are much easier to memorize and recognize in a circle starting with "a" and remembered in opposites. "a" - "g", "b" - "f", "c" - "e" and "d" by itself. Then two hand letters "h" - "z", "i" - "x", "j" - "p", "k" - "v", "l" by itself, "m" - "s", "n" - "u", "o" - "w", "q" - "y", "t" - "numerals", "r" by itself. With over twenty years of practical application (Twice weekly minimum), I never had a problem interpreting flags as overlapping. The only real problem is someone sending the opposite letter like an "x" for an "i" and it was usually done by a novice.I55ere (talk) 18:28, 29 March 2008 (UTC)
There is no "cancel" character. A mis-spelled word is errored out, the receiver sends a "charlie" and the sender then sends the word preceding the mis-spelled word, the correct word and continues with the message. If the whole text is to be cancelled the error sign is given followed by the prosign AR (end of transmission) and the message is cancelled.I55ere (talk) 13:56, 14 June 2008 (UTC)
[edit] References in fiction
- Notice: this discussion's history is available in Talk:Semaphore line
[edit] Fiction:Pokémon
The pokémon Xatu in the pokémon universe is known for using semaphore during the series. 172.147.203.192 19:54, 31 May 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Courage
Aparently, so is Courage the cowardly dog!
[edit] Total rewrite
- Notice: this discussion's history is available in Talk:Semaphore line
I gave this article a total rewrite as per flag --DV8 2XL 04:06, 30 March 2006 (UTC)
- great work man ! :) --Procrastinating@talk2me 08:46, 2 April 2006 (UTC)
- Thanks. --DV8 2XL 10:00, 2 April 2006 (UTC)
[edit] External Link Cleanup
- Notice: this discussion's history is available in Talk:Semaphore line
Hello, I'm just doing a cleanup of the external links for this article. Below are the entries I removed:
- Semaphore online translator (online animated semaphore translator)
- Semaphore Flag Signalling System (shows stick figure waving flags)
- International Maritime Signal Flags (sometimes confused with semaphore flags; shows alphabetic/numeric maritime flags)
- International Maritime Signal Flags (shows the meaning of each flag, and two-letter meanings)
- U. S. Navy Flags (shows the meaning of each flag)
- Maritime Signal Flags (a brief illustrated history of maritime flags)
- World War I and II Royal Navy Flags (historical; shows the meaning of each flag)
- U. S. Storm Signal Flags (pictures and description)
- Automobile Racing Flags (picture and meaning of each flag)
- Skin Diving Flags (pictures and laws of use)
Most of these have nothing to do with semaphore, and instead are talking about marine signalling flags. Two of them are dead links, and one of them is merely a set of images identical in function to those in the article. The two pages Semaphore (comunication) and Semaphore (communication) are both based on the same article but have been copyedited into two different ways. They should be merged. -- JeLuF 10:17 Dec 31, 2002 (UTC)
I'm not sure we need disambiguation for this anyway -- see Talk:Semaphore -- Tarquin 10:28 Dec 31, 2002 (UTC)
I have also remove - A Manual of Signals: For The Use Of Signal Officers In The Field for being some thing about the army, not semaphore...209.247.21.165 14:25, 27 May 2007 (UTC)
A "symbol" and "code" are different things. A "code" is a scheme to translate a string of "symbols" into natural language. I fixed the article. Also, the title is misspelled- "communication" has two "m"s. I don't have time to fix it. (gotta go).
I think this page needs to be merged with optical communication. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus 21:09, 9 Jun 2004 (UTC)
[edit] Copyrighted signals?
- Notice: this discussion's history is available in Talk:Semaphore line
90.241.22.219, in their January 9th, removed the signals for X, Y and Z claiming they were "copyrighted". I don't think flag positions can be. Shouldn't that edit be undone? — Jacobo 14:28, 12 January 2007 (UTC)
- I agree. I put them back. --David Edgar 14:46, 12 January 2007 (UTC)