Category talk:Fictional dinosaurs

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

	This article, image or category is supported by WikiProject Dinosaurs, which aims to improve Wikipedia's coverage of dinosaurs and dinosaur-related topics. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page for more information.
???	This article has not yet received a rating on the quality scale.

[edit] Category scope musing

Contains:

• fictional real dinosaurs

The obvious cases where you have a character that's declared a Stegosaurus and looks like a Stegosaurus and any deviations from a real Stegosaurus are negligible.

• fictional stylised dinosaurs

Best fed with an example: Yoshi. Definitely a 'saurian, but anatomically incorrect.

• fictional dinosaur species

Species that can be identified as 'saurian by anatomy, but were never scientifically discovered. ("That looks a lot like...") E.g. Venatosaurus. Also any creatures mutated (either by time or influence) from a 'saurian, e.g. the original Godzilla.

• fictional characters with a dinosaur form

Covers transformers, power rangers, whichever. I think this may warrant its own category, but I'm going to see just how much would remain of this category if it was split up, before I even begin to do anything of the sort.

Hopefully I'll have the time to count the weight of each 'sub-category' in this category soon. -pinkgothic 13:21, 15 July 2007 (UTC)

Fictional real dinosaurs

Alex (Tekken) (dromeaosaurid), Chomper (tyrannosaurus), Devil Dinosaur (allosaurus), Ducky (The Land Before Time) (saurolophus), List of creatures in Primeval (several), Nervous Rex ('dinosaur'), Old Lace (comics) (deinonychus), Raptor Red (utahraptor)

Fictional stylised dinosaurs

Aggron (Triceratops), Dooly (Ceratosaurus) {pic ref}, Baloney (Animaniacs) (Tyrannosaurus), Bastiodon (ceratopian), Bio-Zoids (several), Casimir (dinosaur) (unspecified, but referred to as a dinosaur), Charmander (theropod), Charmeleon (theropod), Cranidos (pachycephalosaurus), Cubone (therapod or ornithopod, also has a reference to pachycephalosaurus, dodgy), Deadeye (Starriors) (robot tyrannosaurus), Death Saurer (robot tyrannosaurus), List of Dinosaurs characters (several), Gojulas (robot dinosaur), Gojulas Giga (robot Giganotosaurus), Marowak (see reasoning for Cubone), Rampardos (Pachycephalosaurus)

Fictional dinosaur species

Anguirus (mutated; Ankylosaurus), The Bodacious Adventures of Biff Thundersaur (anthropomorph; unknown), Dino (The Flintstones) ('snorkasaurus'), Godzilla (mutated; Iguanodon, Stegosaurus, Tyrannosaurus), Godzilla Junior (mutated; Iguanodon, Stegosaurus, Tyrannosaurus), Godzillasaurus (therapod), Gomora (Jurassic dinosaur), Gon (unknown), Gorgo (film) (carnosaur), Gorosaurus (theropod), Hoppy (hopparoo (kangaroo-dinosaur)), Minilla (see Godzilla reasoning), Quintaglio (theropod)

Fictional characters with a dinosaur form

The Abarangers, Zords in Power Rangers: Dino Thunder, Dinobot, Dinobots, Dinoforce, Dinotron, Grimlock, Killerpunch, Magmatron, Megatron (Beast Wars and Beast Machines), Zords in Mighty Morphin Power Rangers, Rapticon, Razorclaw

Others that were kept

Bulbasaur, Ivysaur - See Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Dinosaurs#Category: Fictional dinosaurs about characters ending with -saur.

Mesogog - expressly mentioned as being a dinosaur-human hybrid.

Removed: Baragon (therapsid), King Bowser (a Koopa), Dino: World Premiere Toons (recategorised to Dinosaurs in fiction)

Notes

1. Dooly is categorised under 'Baby-Saurus Dooly', putting it - quite inexplicably - into the 'B' section of Fictional dinosaurs. As it's a global flag being set in the article, I'm hesitant to change it. I'm going to bring it up on the article's talk page later.
2. Barugon is a monster with no reference to dinosaurs, but, unlike Baragon, no reference to something else, either. As such, I'm going to see if I can find sources claiming either (later).
3. The Bodacious Adventures of Biff Thundersaur - comic book, not the character. Category:Dinosaurs in fiction more apt once more?
4. Jiger - there are pages comparing Jiger to a horned dinosaur, and indeed, the similarity is there, but it does seem to be something else entirely. Still, I can see edit wars arise over this.
5. Baragon had the category re-added. It's been re-removed and a notice has been put onto the article's talk page.
6. King Bowser seems to be in dispute. While he is definitely a Koopa, which are called turtles, there's a paragraph in the article referring to his role in a movie, where "Dinohattan" is mentioned, along with him being some kind of mutated Tyrannosaur. So this is now being discussed there. (Talk page)
7. Kangaskhan had the category re-added without comment. I've removed it again and requested the placement to be discussed on the talk page.
8. Lizalfos look a lot like dinosaurians even under scrutiny, though the articles refer to them as man-like lizards, and even go so far as to mention Dinolfos as "dinosaur variants of Lizalfos". So, the article's wording is in favour of getting it removed, but I'm not. Hm.

1. Prickle (Gumby character) - the article seems unclear whether Prickle is a dragon or a dinosaur, itself. It provides references for both. Kept for now.

Resolved

1. I categorised Barney & Friends here, since I stumbled across it from Barney the Dinosaur. After brief input from User:TTN, it was categorised into Category:Dinosaurs in fiction instead, where the show belongs.