Wikipedia:Factual review/reviews/Pipes (example) (one)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] Pipes
Pipes — factual review initiated on March 19, 2008.
Due to the fact that the article on "Pipes" covers an important topic, has not been factually reviewed before, and appears to be well-written, I request that it be factually reviewed. — Thomas H. Larsen 08:05, 20 March 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Article sections
If you wish to participate in this factual review, and you are reasonably knowledgeable about the topic of the article, please assign your name to one or more of the sections listed below. You should be knowledgeable in the sections you intend to review. More than one editor can review one section, but all sections of the article must be reviewed.
[edit] Summary
Factual reviewers: Plumber, Piper
The "Summary" section of the article claims that "... pipes are useless ...", which appears (a) unverifiable, and (b) heavily biased. — Piper
The "Summary" section claims that "... pipes are always grey ...", which is most definitely inaccurate and unverifiable. — Plumber
[edit] Uses of pipes
Factual reviewers: PipeUser, Pied Piper, Plumber
[edit] Types of pipes
Factual reviewers: SquarePipe, Pied Piper, Round Pipe, Cylinder
[edit] Materials of pipes
Factual reviewers: Plastic, Steel Tube
This section of the article claims that "... [a]ll pipes are made from plastic ...", which is false and unverifiable. — Steel Tube
I feel that this section fails to provide adequate coverage, especially in regards to varying materials of pipes — plastic, wooden, stone, concrete, steel, and others. — Plastic
[edit] Construction of pipes
Factual reviewers: Piper, Steel Tube
[edit] History of pipes
Factual reviewers: Plumber
[edit] Footnotes
Factual reviewers: Notetaker, Foot
